Review of Israel: The Demonization of an Ethical Country
-
Nhya L
- Posts: 18
- Joined: 13 Mar 2022, 17:08
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 11
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-nhya-l.html
- Latest Review: Working From Home: Making It Work For You by Thomas Engblom
Review of Israel: The Demonization of an Ethical Country
[Following is a volunteer review of "Israel: The Demonization of an Ethical Country" by Sean Melamed.]
Israel: The Demonization of an Ethical Country by Sean Melamed is a nonfiction book that attempts to defend the image of the state of Israel. The author presents arguments concerning Israel and the mainstream media, commonly accepted falsehoods about Israel, and the country’s international perception. They aim to clarify discussion surrounding the ongoing conflict between Israel and Palestine.
The book is organized into five sections, each focusing on antisemitism and the negative portrayal of Israel in the media. For example, the author presents the chapters “Biased Reporting,” “The Media as a Weapon,” “Why Does the Media Hate Israel,” and “The Media Contribute to Antisemitism” in the section titled “Israel and the Mainstream Media.” The chapters “Vicious Antisemitism Among Liberals” and “Ideological Purity” appear in the section “Liberals and Israel.” Across sections, the author presents overlapping ideas. The structure is clear but repetitive, and the flow of information makes it evident that the author fiercely desires a pro-Israel takeaway from the book.
The tone of Israel: The Demonization of an Ethical Country is informal, persuasive, and opinionated. The author uses personal anecdotes, ad hominem attacks, quotes, and data to support their arguments. However, no sources are cited to verify the claims made.
The book is accessible in terms of readability, but I noticed several formatting issues. The author frequently uses run-on sentences and unclear phrasing. Additionally, the sections of the book are uneven. Some contain fourteen chapters, while others contain only three.
While the author’s passion is evident, the emotional tone often detracts from the objectivity expected in nonfiction. The arguments rely heavily on personal opinion, and in some places, the logic feels flawed or oversimplified. For example, the author argues that the creation of a Palestinian state would greatly intensify global problems, but fails to provide sufficient evidence beyond his personal assertions. In general, the book would benefit from engaging with opposing viewpoints to offer a more balanced understanding.
This book is likely intended for readers who already agree with the premise that the media is unfairly critical of Israel. Readers unfamiliar with the topic may find it either interesting or offensive, depending on their background and perspective.
I rate this book 1 out of 4 and 2 out of 5 stars. I deducted points due to the lack of credible evidence and the author’s extreme bias. This book may appeal to readers who are already sympathetic to the author’s stance. However, the Israel-Palestine conflict is a centuries-old, sensitive, and complicated issue that the author does not handle with care. I would not recommend it to readers seeking a comprehensive or balanced overview of the conflict.
******
Israel: The Demonization of an Ethical Country
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon
Israel: The Demonization of an Ethical Country by Sean Melamed is a nonfiction book that attempts to defend the image of the state of Israel. The author presents arguments concerning Israel and the mainstream media, commonly accepted falsehoods about Israel, and the country’s international perception. They aim to clarify discussion surrounding the ongoing conflict between Israel and Palestine.
The book is organized into five sections, each focusing on antisemitism and the negative portrayal of Israel in the media. For example, the author presents the chapters “Biased Reporting,” “The Media as a Weapon,” “Why Does the Media Hate Israel,” and “The Media Contribute to Antisemitism” in the section titled “Israel and the Mainstream Media.” The chapters “Vicious Antisemitism Among Liberals” and “Ideological Purity” appear in the section “Liberals and Israel.” Across sections, the author presents overlapping ideas. The structure is clear but repetitive, and the flow of information makes it evident that the author fiercely desires a pro-Israel takeaway from the book.
The tone of Israel: The Demonization of an Ethical Country is informal, persuasive, and opinionated. The author uses personal anecdotes, ad hominem attacks, quotes, and data to support their arguments. However, no sources are cited to verify the claims made.
The book is accessible in terms of readability, but I noticed several formatting issues. The author frequently uses run-on sentences and unclear phrasing. Additionally, the sections of the book are uneven. Some contain fourteen chapters, while others contain only three.
While the author’s passion is evident, the emotional tone often detracts from the objectivity expected in nonfiction. The arguments rely heavily on personal opinion, and in some places, the logic feels flawed or oversimplified. For example, the author argues that the creation of a Palestinian state would greatly intensify global problems, but fails to provide sufficient evidence beyond his personal assertions. In general, the book would benefit from engaging with opposing viewpoints to offer a more balanced understanding.
This book is likely intended for readers who already agree with the premise that the media is unfairly critical of Israel. Readers unfamiliar with the topic may find it either interesting or offensive, depending on their background and perspective.
I rate this book 1 out of 4 and 2 out of 5 stars. I deducted points due to the lack of credible evidence and the author’s extreme bias. This book may appeal to readers who are already sympathetic to the author’s stance. However, the Israel-Palestine conflict is a centuries-old, sensitive, and complicated issue that the author does not handle with care. I would not recommend it to readers seeking a comprehensive or balanced overview of the conflict.
******
Israel: The Demonization of an Ethical Country
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon
Latest Review: Working From Home: Making It Work For You by Thomas Engblom
