Review by SRedmon47 -- Commitment to Courage
-
SRedmon47
- Posts: 1
- Joined: 16 Oct 2020, 22:11
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 0
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-sredmon47.html
- Latest Review: Commitment to Courage by Donald L. Redden PhD
Review by SRedmon47 -- Commitment to Courage
[Following is a volunteer review of "Commitment to Courage" by Donald L. Redden PhD.]
Commitment To Courage by Donald L. Redden, Ph.D., was a fairly easy read. I would rate this book 2 out of 4 stars because of its lack of specific detail. As a former prosecutor, my expectations for specific detail regarding Redden’s investigations were especially high, however, I found this detail lacking. His military service and later law enforcement career speaks volumes regarding his public service, and should, in every way be recognized and lauded. This book, as a biographical sketch of his life, was a good record of his achievements, but it was not filled with the content that would make the reader not want to put it down.
Those readers that have not had experience in law enforcement or have family that are involved with law enforcement, may be intrigued by the different encounters the author relates in this book. However, as stated above, those, like myself, who have this experience, would really like more detail. For example, what kind of firearms did they use during this time period? The F.B.I., as one of the elite law enforcement agencies in the nation, would have access to anything cutting-edge. What kind of investigative techniques did they use, and what progression in this area was he able to witness throughout his years of service. While he retired in 1995, it is obvious that the cell phone technology and other internet landmarks are not what they are today. But, knowing now what is available to assist with the apprehension of criminals versus what was utilized in his day, would make interesting reading for those that might be compelled to read this type of book.
With that said, the grammar, spelling, sentence structure, and overall readability were sufficient. There were very few errors detected which evidences good writing and editing. The fact that Redden was a soldier and law enforcement officer, especially within the context of the state of our nation today, is a story that needs to be told. Too many times, those that put themselves on the front lines or in harms way to insure that we, as United States citizens, have the freedoms granted to us by the Constitution, are ridiculed and vilified to such an extent that many soon forget just how important these particular callings truly are, and appears to cause much second guessing of the new generation of folks that would fill the retired shoes of those like Redden.
Some of the detail that was included regarding his time as a soldier, caused me to see, if only a little peak, into the cares and concerns of those on the front lines. The detail provided of his life outside of his duties as a soldier and law enforcement officer allows readers to witness or experience the side effects that come with these particular occupations. The direct hazards from the requirements of the job, along with those domestic hazards that are prevalent in the lives of those in these specific occupations, give a partial overview to those that may be considering similar paths.
Overall, based on my background and experience, I found this book a small disappointment. I would reiterate that I am truly thankful for Redden’s service and all he has done for our country. I have deep respect for him and those like him that have chosen this path for their lives. But from the standpoint of intriguing reading, this is found wanting.
******
Commitment to Courage
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon
Commitment To Courage by Donald L. Redden, Ph.D., was a fairly easy read. I would rate this book 2 out of 4 stars because of its lack of specific detail. As a former prosecutor, my expectations for specific detail regarding Redden’s investigations were especially high, however, I found this detail lacking. His military service and later law enforcement career speaks volumes regarding his public service, and should, in every way be recognized and lauded. This book, as a biographical sketch of his life, was a good record of his achievements, but it was not filled with the content that would make the reader not want to put it down.
Those readers that have not had experience in law enforcement or have family that are involved with law enforcement, may be intrigued by the different encounters the author relates in this book. However, as stated above, those, like myself, who have this experience, would really like more detail. For example, what kind of firearms did they use during this time period? The F.B.I., as one of the elite law enforcement agencies in the nation, would have access to anything cutting-edge. What kind of investigative techniques did they use, and what progression in this area was he able to witness throughout his years of service. While he retired in 1995, it is obvious that the cell phone technology and other internet landmarks are not what they are today. But, knowing now what is available to assist with the apprehension of criminals versus what was utilized in his day, would make interesting reading for those that might be compelled to read this type of book.
With that said, the grammar, spelling, sentence structure, and overall readability were sufficient. There were very few errors detected which evidences good writing and editing. The fact that Redden was a soldier and law enforcement officer, especially within the context of the state of our nation today, is a story that needs to be told. Too many times, those that put themselves on the front lines or in harms way to insure that we, as United States citizens, have the freedoms granted to us by the Constitution, are ridiculed and vilified to such an extent that many soon forget just how important these particular callings truly are, and appears to cause much second guessing of the new generation of folks that would fill the retired shoes of those like Redden.
Some of the detail that was included regarding his time as a soldier, caused me to see, if only a little peak, into the cares and concerns of those on the front lines. The detail provided of his life outside of his duties as a soldier and law enforcement officer allows readers to witness or experience the side effects that come with these particular occupations. The direct hazards from the requirements of the job, along with those domestic hazards that are prevalent in the lives of those in these specific occupations, give a partial overview to those that may be considering similar paths.
Overall, based on my background and experience, I found this book a small disappointment. I would reiterate that I am truly thankful for Redden’s service and all he has done for our country. I have deep respect for him and those like him that have chosen this path for their lives. But from the standpoint of intriguing reading, this is found wanting.
******
Commitment to Courage
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon
Latest Review: Commitment to Courage by Donald L. Redden PhD
