OnlineBookClub.org

[Following is a volunteer review of "The 13th of Summer" by Charlene Pratt.]

In the early part of this book, it feels a bit slow because I didn't fully understand the background of the story. As someone born in Southeast Asia, I needed to read more about the Dust Bowl event, Black Blizzard, and the effects of the Great Depression briefly before I could fully immerse myself in this reading.

The book is themed as historical fiction with a touch of romance and many sad stories. Set in South Dakota, Central America, the book tells the struggles of the people there facing a decade-long climate crisis.

The details in the story are well described to depict the conditions, with children always advised to stay indoors, relentless blowing sand dust, drought, and poverty haunting the community there.

Our main character, Betty, lives and grows up as a young girl with many siblings, managing their farm there.

Growing up during dust storms, economic crises, and droughts is not easy. Our main character has to face unexpected sorrows in the story and continue to struggle with her daily life.

Her daily life as a girl, with household routines and farming, is well explained, as if we were truly living with Betty at that time.

Despite their various difficult circumstances, there are many moments of happiness together, resilience, sincerity, and how the townsfolk unite against the capitalists in those difficult conditions.

I am impressed with how the author portrays Betty's father as a complex figure who tries to remain strong even though he has to lose his beloved child several times. Even when losing two of his children towards the end of the story, he keeps it all to himself and chooses to cry alone.

This book is easy to read and has an amazing, flawless, and perfect editing.

I give this book a 5 out of 5 because of the character portrayal, which I find well-developed and complex despite the fairly simple theme of the story. Each character has internal struggles that we can read about in the book, portrayed well so that we can empathize with their feelings.

The shortcomings of this book may be the lack of explanation about the context of the story at the beginning for people who do not understand the events of famine, the Great Depression, and the black blizzard at that time. In the early part, the plot also feels somewhat slow and less interesting.

Nevertheless, the story starts to become interesting when the crisis begins and the characters struggle together as a caring and helping family.

The end of the story also leaves a bittersweet impression, which I think is in line with the theme of the story, which teaches us that life does not always have a happy ending but needs to be accepted because it is the complexity of life that makes the story interesting to tell to our grandchildren.

This book is good for people who enjoy themes of nostalgia, historical fiction, family, and the struggles of life.

******
The 13th of Summer
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon

The writing style of the review is indeed unique. It's unfortunate that you had to do some research before reading the book, but we do learn something new every day.

I believe this emotional book will cater to my taste. A detailed review from you!

Your review offers a thorough and insightful perspective on the book, highlighting its strengths in character development and thematic depth. You effectively convey how the story's historical context initially posed a challenge but ultimately enhanced your appreciation for the narrative. Your detailed observations about the portrayal of the main character, Betty, and her father's resilience add a poignant touch, illustrating the emotional richness of the story. While noting the slow start and the need for more background information, your overall positive assessment and recommendation for readers interested in historical fiction and family struggles provide a balanced and compelling endorsement.

One little tiny nudge on the review: South Dakota is in North America, rather than Central. It is however in the central part of North America, so that is cool! The South Dakotan landscape is very much the same now as it was back in the time in which this book is set: austere, flat, dusty, unforgiving, with freezing cold winters. The Depression plus the Dust Bowl, about 100 years ago … WOW, that must’ve been a very hostile place. Sounds like quite a fascinating book! Thanks for the review, Tony, I always enjoy yours

Excellent review! You've beautifully captured the essence of the book's themes and the rich historical backdrop that frames the characters' lives. It's insightful to hear how you navigated the initial challenges due to cultural differences, adding depth to your understanding of the story.

Historical fiction is a genre I like very much. Also, the story looks interesting. Although I will have to read more about Black Blizzard and the Great Depression, for the same reason you did.

I appreciate how you highlighted the initial challenge of understanding the historical context, which underscores the importance of familiarizing oneself with events like the Dust Bowl and the Great Depression to fully appreciate the story. The way the author portrays the resilience and unity of the community, along with the complex emotions of Betty's father, makes the story feel authentic and deeply moving.

I will enjoy this story that blends historical fiction, tragedy, resilience, and community and family values. I have heard of the Great Depression, but the Dust Bowl and the Black Bizzard, I have not heard of. I am looking forward to this educational read. Great review.

This reflective review of "The Dust Bowl Daughter" underscores its immersive portrayal of historical events and family struggles amidst crisis. As per reviewer ,while initially slow-paced for readers unfamiliar with the Dust Bowl era, the book gains momentum as it delves into Betty's experiences navigating challenges like dust storms and economic hardship in South Dakota. The author skill-fully develops complex characters, notably Betty's father, who grapples with personal grief amidst collective adversity. Despite minor pacing issues at the start, the book earns a perfect rating of 5 out of 5 for its poignant character portrayal and bittersweet narrative that captures the essence of life's complexities. The reviewer recommended this book for readers drawn to themes of nostalgia, historical fiction, and resilience in the face of hardship.

Thank you for your insightful review of this historical fiction novel set during the Dust Bowl and the Great Depression. Your thoughtful observations provide a comprehensive overview of the book's strengths and the challenges you faced as a reader from Southeast Asia.

Your dedication to understanding the historical context of the Dust Bowl, Black Blizzards, and the Great Depression is commendable. This effort undoubtedly enriched your reading experience, allowing you to fully appreciate the struggles and resilience of the characters in South Dakota.

The way you describe the novel's setting and atmosphere—children advised to stay indoors, relentless sand dust, drought, and poverty—paints a vivid picture of the harsh conditions faced by the community. Your description of Betty's life, from her household routines to managing the farm and dealing with personal sorrows, brings her character to life. It's clear that the author succeeded in creating an immersive and emotionally engaging narrative.

The portrayal of Betty's father as a complex figure who remains strong despite immense personal loss is particularly poignant. Your empathy for his character, and for the family as they navigate their hardships, highlights the author's skill in developing well-rounded and relatable characters.

Your critique about the initial lack of historical context for readers unfamiliar with the era is valuable feedback. This observation underscores the importance of providing background information to help readers fully engage with the story from the beginning. Despite this, your review indicates that the novel's pace and interest level pick up as the crisis intensifies and the characters' resilience shines through.

The bittersweet ending, which aligns with the story's theme of life's complexities, is a fitting conclusion that adds depth to the narrative. Your recommendation for readers who enjoy themes of nostalgia, historical fiction, family, and life's struggles is well-founded.

Overall, your review beautifully captures the essence of the book, emphasizing its emotional depth, historical richness, and the well-developed characters that drive the story. Thank you for sharing your experience and insights, which will surely help other readers appreciate this novel's merits.

This historical fiction with a touch of romance and many sad stories is set in South Dakota, Central America. It tells us about the struggles of the people there facing a decade-long climate crisis. I appreciate that the story continues at a brisk pace. Your review is beautiful and captures the essence of the book perfectly. Thank you.

Great read Tomy. I like the fact that this book is not just a cliche with a happy ending because unfortunately that's not how life is. The arrangement of the book sounds enlightening. I can already feel the rollercoaster of emotions you had to go through while reading it and that's amazing. Well done on this particular read

I really admire how you can admit you don't know enough about something to actually enjoy a book and always do your own research to understand more. I have to say that while I obviously knew about the Great Depression, I'd never even heard about the Dust Bowl event or the Black Blizzard. This is why niche books like this one are so important - there's just so much we don't know, and stories are the best way we can actually touch other people's lives. Thanks for this review!

An interesting book.
I am already resonating with Betty's father in that he " chooses to cry alone."
Betty's life is interesting, and clearly, there is much to learn from her, considering how she deals with her challenging environment and life circumstances.
I believe a book like this can only be a reference point for identifying with gratitude for where we are and the things we can proactively do to take care of our environment.
I appreciate your mention of the shortcomings of the book as well, in terms of the basic background information required to enjoy and connect with the author's story.
Congratulations to the author!