Review of That's what Ed said
-
Chetan Lohia
- Posts: 3
- Joined: 29 Jun 2025, 23:24
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 0
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-chetan-lohia.html
Review of That's what Ed said
[Following is a volunteer review of "That's what Ed said" by U A Dumas.]
Title: That's What Ed Said
Author: U.A. Dumas
Publication Date: November 25, 2022
Length: 202 pages
Book Review:
U.A. Dumas’s That’s What Ed Said is a compelling and candid exploration of a tumultuous life marked by struggle, resilience, and redemption. The narrative follows Leslie Edward Dumas, a former delinquent whose journey from a troubled youth to a respected high school math teacher and principal unfolds with raw honesty and vivid detail. Spanning several decades, the book presents a semi-autobiographical coming-of-age story that delves deeply into the complexities of addiction, personal demons, and the quest for control over one’s life.
The story’s plot is an unvarnished portrayal of Ed’s life, filled with episodes of substance abuse, sexual content, and intense human relationships. It is both a personal memoir and a broader reflection on life’s hardships and triumphs. The author’s experience as a former teacher lends authenticity to the depiction of school life and the challenges Ed faces in his professional and personal spheres.
Characters in That’s What Ed Said are depicted with nuance and depth. Ed himself is a multifaceted protagonist—mischievous and rebellious in his youth, yet capable of love, responsibility, and success as an adult. Supporting characters enrich the narrative, highlighting themes of friendship, loyalty, and second chances. The emotional resonance of these relationships contributes significantly to the story’s impact.
Thematically, the book confronts difficult subjects such as addiction, self-destruction, and redemption. It also touches on darker events, including treachery and murder, underscoring the chaotic and sometimes violent backdrop against which Ed’s story unfolds. Despite this, the narrative conveys a hopeful message about the possibility of growth and success despite a troubled past.
Dumas’s writing style is straightforward and engaging, balancing humor with serious reflection. The prose is accessible yet evocative, capturing the authentic voice of the protagonist and immersing the reader in a vivid, often gritty world. The storytelling is marked by its unfiltered approach, which some readers may find challenging but many will appreciate for its honesty and depth.
Strengths of this work lie in its raw portrayal of a complicated life and its refusal to shy away from uncomfortable truths. The book’s authenticity and emotional depth make it a valuable read for those interested in stories of personal transformation and the human condition. While the sometimes chaotic structure and intense subject matter may not appeal to all readers, the overall effect is a powerful and thought-provoking narrative.
In conclusion, That’s What Ed Said stands as a noteworthy contribution to contemporary memoir-style fiction. U.A. Dumas offers an unflinching look at a life shaped by adversity and perseverance, delivering a story that is both deeply personal and universally resonant. This book is recommended for readers seeking an honest, multifaceted portrayal of struggle and redemption.
******
That's what Ed said
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon
Title: That's What Ed Said
Author: U.A. Dumas
Publication Date: November 25, 2022
Length: 202 pages
Book Review:
U.A. Dumas’s That’s What Ed Said is a compelling and candid exploration of a tumultuous life marked by struggle, resilience, and redemption. The narrative follows Leslie Edward Dumas, a former delinquent whose journey from a troubled youth to a respected high school math teacher and principal unfolds with raw honesty and vivid detail. Spanning several decades, the book presents a semi-autobiographical coming-of-age story that delves deeply into the complexities of addiction, personal demons, and the quest for control over one’s life.
The story’s plot is an unvarnished portrayal of Ed’s life, filled with episodes of substance abuse, sexual content, and intense human relationships. It is both a personal memoir and a broader reflection on life’s hardships and triumphs. The author’s experience as a former teacher lends authenticity to the depiction of school life and the challenges Ed faces in his professional and personal spheres.
Characters in That’s What Ed Said are depicted with nuance and depth. Ed himself is a multifaceted protagonist—mischievous and rebellious in his youth, yet capable of love, responsibility, and success as an adult. Supporting characters enrich the narrative, highlighting themes of friendship, loyalty, and second chances. The emotional resonance of these relationships contributes significantly to the story’s impact.
Thematically, the book confronts difficult subjects such as addiction, self-destruction, and redemption. It also touches on darker events, including treachery and murder, underscoring the chaotic and sometimes violent backdrop against which Ed’s story unfolds. Despite this, the narrative conveys a hopeful message about the possibility of growth and success despite a troubled past.
Dumas’s writing style is straightforward and engaging, balancing humor with serious reflection. The prose is accessible yet evocative, capturing the authentic voice of the protagonist and immersing the reader in a vivid, often gritty world. The storytelling is marked by its unfiltered approach, which some readers may find challenging but many will appreciate for its honesty and depth.
Strengths of this work lie in its raw portrayal of a complicated life and its refusal to shy away from uncomfortable truths. The book’s authenticity and emotional depth make it a valuable read for those interested in stories of personal transformation and the human condition. While the sometimes chaotic structure and intense subject matter may not appeal to all readers, the overall effect is a powerful and thought-provoking narrative.
In conclusion, That’s What Ed Said stands as a noteworthy contribution to contemporary memoir-style fiction. U.A. Dumas offers an unflinching look at a life shaped by adversity and perseverance, delivering a story that is both deeply personal and universally resonant. This book is recommended for readers seeking an honest, multifaceted portrayal of struggle and redemption.
******
That's what Ed said
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon
