Review of The Band That Time Forgot

[Robert Atunda]

[Following is an official OnlineBookClub.org review of "The Band That Time Forgot" by Dennis Coath.]

---

5 out of 5 stars

---

Share This Review

---

Dennis Coath’s “The Band That Time Forgot” is a compelling narrative that captures the essence of rock and roll, the passage of time, and the enduring power of dreams. This novel tells the story of The Dogs, a rock band from 1962 whose dreams of stardom are dashed when their song, “Treat Me Like a Dog,” fails to chart, overshadowed by the meteoric rise of The Beatles. Decades later, the band reunites for a final recording session, leading to an unexpected resurgence in their careers. The novel explores themes of nostalgia, redemption, friendship, and adaptation, making it a rich and engaging read.

The novel is structured around the band’s journey from their hopeful beginnings in 1962 to their unexpected comeback decades later. The story begins with the band members dreaming of fame, facing setbacks as The Beatles overshadow them, and eventually disbanding. The plot then shifts to the future, showing how chance reunites them, leading to a surprising second chance at stardom. This dual timeline effectively contrasts the vibrant 1960s music scene with the challenges of modern-day revival, providing depth to the characters’ journeys.

Themes

Nostalgia and Time: The book delves deeply into the theme of nostalgia, exploring how the characters reflect on their past glories and failures. The passage of time and its impact on dreams and relationships is a central theme.
Redemption and Second Chances: The Dogs’ journey underscores the possibility of redemption and the idea that it’s never too late to pursue one’s dreams.
Friendship and Loyalty: The relationships among the band members, strained yet resilient, highlight the importance of loyalty and camaraderie.
Change and Adaptation: The band’s ability to adapt to the new music industry landscape and their personal growth are crucial elements of the story.
Characters

Lenny ‘Poddy’ Peabody: A central figure in the band whose son later helps rekindle their success.
James ‘Smudger’ Smith: Another key member whose reconnection with Streaky initiates the band’s comeback.
Brian ‘Streaky’ Bacon and Charlie ‘Biffo’ Bear: Essential members whose talents and personalities add depth to the band’s dynamic.
Buddy: Poddy’s son, who plays a pivotal role in reviving The Dogs’ music.
The character development is rich, showing the personal growth of each band member over time. The relationship between Poddy and his son Buddy is particularly poignant, symbolizing generational bridging and the enduring legacy of music. Streaky and Smudger’s reconnection highlights themes of reconciliation and the enduring bond formed through shared experiences.

Coath’s writing is characterized by its descriptive nature and attention to the emotional states of his characters. The narrative shifts seamlessly between past and present, providing a rich tapestry of the band’s history and individual backstories. The vivid depiction of the 1960s music scene brings a sense of authenticity and charm, while the modern-day setting illustrates the passage of time and the changes within the band and society. This book is exceptionally well-edited with no grammatical errors or typos.

The Dogs’ Song “Treat Me Like a Dog”: Symbolizes their initial failure and later redemption. Its transformation from an overlooked track to a hit represents the band’s journey.
Encounters with The Beatles: Serve as a metaphor for missed opportunities and the harsh realities of the music industry.
Radio Play of the Song: Duke Deckster playing “You Treat Me Like a Dog” symbolizes a turning point, representing the power of media and the potential for rediscovery and revival in the digital age.

The novel reflects the cultural shifts from the 1960s to the present, capturing the evolution of the music industry, societal changes, and the enduring appeal of rock and roll. It touches on the impact of fame, the fleeting nature of success, and the relentless passage of time. The Dogs’ ability to regroup and attempt a comeback despite their age and the industry’s changes underscores a broader message of resilience. It highlights the idea that passion and talent can transcend time, and adaptability is key to enduring success.

While the novel may evoke nostalgia for readers familiar with the 1960s music scene, it also offers universal themes of friendship, perseverance, and the enduring power of music. Its character-driven narrative and emotional depth are likely to resonate with a wide audience, making it both a heartfelt homage to the past and an inspiring story of new beginnings.

In conclusion, “The Band That Time Forgot” is a multifaceted novel that blends historical context with personal narratives, creating a compelling story about a band’s journey through time. Dennis Coath’s detailed characterization and thematic richness make this book a poignant read for anyone interested in the human side of the music industry. The novel’s balance of nostalgia and hope, combined with its rich character development and thematic depth, earns it a well-deserved rating of 5 out of 5 stars.

******
The Band That Time Forgot
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon

[Sandre Lamar]

This book is a captivating tale of dreams, redemption, and the enduring power of rock and roll.

[Slippy Spectrum]

Hey, this review really captures the essence of rock and roll and the enduring power of dreams. The plot seems interesting, shifting between the band's rise in the 60s and their unexpected comeback. The themes of nostalgia, redemption, friendship, and adaptation make it a rich and engaging read. The characters' personal growth over time and their relationships add depth to the story. The writing is descriptive and the dual timeline provides a great contrast. The book seems like a heartfelt homage to the past and an inspiring story of new beginnings. I'd definitely rate it a solid 5 out of 5. You should check it out! Compelling characters, felt fully developed and multidimensional.