Official Review: L’Amérique by Thierry Sagnier

Manang Muyang · Post by **Manang Muyang** » 08 Nov 2018, 04:15

[Following is an official OnlineBookClub.org review of "L’Amérique" by Thierry Sagnier.]

3 out of 4 stars

Share This Review

Meet Jeanot in L’Amerique. He is a ten-year-old Parisian boy who immigrates to the United States in the late 1950s. While author Thierry Sagnier identifies his work as fiction, I have a strong feeling that it is largely based on his own childhood. Thierry is French-born and moved to America as a young boy.

The story starts with Jeanot in post-WWII Paris. We encounter the wacky people in his Paris life: his Papa and Maman, his Oncle Yves, his great-aunt Tatie, their building concierge and several maids, their American-family tenant, his best friend Babette, and his rival for Babette’s affections, Dede. Many of Jeanot’s experiences are hilarious. Part of the tenant’s rent is paid via delightful PX goods. His quirky Oncle Yves has amorous designs on his Papa. The concierge Kharkov, a Russian émigré, regales Jeanot with his expert knowledge of American trivia, some of which are ridiculous exaggerations. We also see Jeanot face some boyhood difficulties, including punishment (usually he has “all four cheeks afire”) for his mischiefs and puppy-love heartaches. Then, for reasons not clear to Jeanot, his parents decide to move to America.

What happens next is a little boy’s awakening to a new culture. His fantasy world of cowboys and Indians, his Maman’s vision that everything good happens in America, and Kharkov’s dream destination: are these what Les Etats Unis will prove to be?

We are effortlessly transported to 1950s France and America, with the author naming famous symbols of those times. Acclaimed filmmaker Jean Cocteau (of the first Beauty and the Beast film), Coco Chanel, kid magazines Tintin and Spirou, Le General Charles de Gaulle, Procter & Gamble’s Tide and Prell, Tyrone Power (who played Zorro), and the musical Oklahoma! are some. We see that era through the eyes of a young boy, with his refreshing naivete and curiosity.

The book was a pleasure to read; the author’s wit had me chuckling a lot. I don’t know if parents will allow their young kids to enjoy the story, though, as there are references to adultery, inaccurate childish lessons about “the birds and the bees,” and some swearing, mostly in French (pun intended).

I learned from the author’s website that the story was rewritten more than a hundred times, and the editor wielded the “chainsaw” with “much glee.” Big chunks of original material were chopped. That is perhaps the reason why there are a few plot holes. For instance, chapter one happens in 1955 while the party in chapter two transpires on April Fools’ Day of 1952 without mention of a flashback. Chapter two also states that Jeanot’s family moved residence, but this is not evident from the rest of the story.

The heavy editing also didn’t sweep all the errors as I still found quite a few misspellings and punctuation issues. The author likewise included a generous helping of French words and sentences. While many of these were understandable from the context, I had to look up several to make sure I was reading the lines correctly. These minor irritants did not detract from the reading enjoyment, but they cost the book one star.

I recommend this book to all who want to experience 1950s France and America and how it was after WWII in the eyes of a child. The innocent recounting of the war does not dull the message that war is horrible. Jeanot talks about Jews with tattoos, another character recalls French collaborators executing women and children at Vel d’Hiv, and Jeanot’s Papa still gets bouts of malaria which he caught during the war.

The book is also for those who carry the American dream in their hearts. They will read about Jeanot’s experiences as a “furner.” May they not be displeased to know that like most places on this planet, America is not heaven (even before Trump).

L’ Amerique gets 3 out of 4 stars from me. I hope I do not disappoint Thierry who says of the book: “Frankly, I think we have a winner.” But I would say that it came very close.

******
L’Amérique
View: on Bookshelves

Like Miriam Molina's review? Post a comment saying so!

Franc93 · Post by **Franc93** » 09 Nov 2018, 00:27

If any one said time travel does not exist, this is the proof that it does. The review is precise and in depth it is almost like i am in France.

Sara Kay · Post by **Sara Kay** » 09 Nov 2018, 01:14

I love books that transport you into different cultures and experiences. Your description of the book is very captivating. I think I would read this despite the errors and inconsistencies you mention. Thank you for your beautiful review!

Manang Muyang · Post by **Manang Muyang** » 09 Nov 2018, 01:37

Franc93 wrote: ↑09 Nov 2018, 00:27 If any one said time travel does not exist, this is the proof that it does. The review is precise and in depth it is almost like i am in France.

Merci! You will enjoy Jeanot's memorable experiences. Your name was French money before the euro took over.

Manang Muyang · Post by **Manang Muyang** » 09 Nov 2018, 01:38

Sara Kay wrote: ↑09 Nov 2018, 01:14 I love books that transport you into different cultures and experiences. Your description of the book is very captivating. I think I would read this despite the errors and inconsistencies you mention. Thank you for your beautiful review!

Yes, go ahead! Thierry is a wonderful storyteller. Thanks for the kind words.

Sonya Nicolaidis · Post by **Sonya Nicolaidis** » 09 Nov 2018, 02:53

Somehow from reading your review, I am drawn to reading this book. I think it has something to do with the whimsical feel it has of a boy growing up far from home, and tackling all these new challenges in a humorous way. The time setting is also one that appeals to me, when things weren’t so dark and shadowy. Lovely review. Well done!

T_stone · Post by **T_stone** » 09 Nov 2018, 05:07

This is an interesting review; it has piqued my interest in reading this book. Therefore, I'm adding this to my list of TBR books. Thanks for the detailed review.

Dael Reader · Post by **Dael Reader** » 09 Nov 2018, 08:30

It sounds like this book is a gem that just needs to be polished up a bit more to truly shine. Nice review.

Post by **kandscreeley** » 09 Nov 2018, 08:36

It's nice that the author has some humor in the telling of his story; that makes it a bit more special in my eyes. Having lived in America my whole life, I do wonder about the culture shock that immigrants face. Thanks for the interesting review.

gen_g · Post by **gen_g** » 09 Nov 2018, 11:30

This sounds like such a great book! However, it's such a pity about the plot holes! I'm interested in 1950s France, and I'll definitely look out for a copy! Thanks for the review!

Bianka Walter · Post by **Bianka Walter** » 09 Nov 2018, 14:20

I loved Spirou and Fantasio! Wow, it's amazing how time dulls memories of the things we loved when we were younger. It seems that the author remembered the time quite well, though.
It's a pity that the well-intentioned editor didn't do a final thorough sweep.
This sounds great

kfwilson6 · Post by **kfwilson6** » 09 Nov 2018, 15:19

I love the way you phrase things like his Oncle having amorous designs and the birds and the bees. I like the reminiscent aspect of this, but I'm not very interested in American history.

Post by **Sushan Ekanayake** » 10 Nov 2018, 14:08

This sort of books are not my taste but, I enjoyed your review. Thank you

Post by **Alice Heritage** » 10 Nov 2018, 16:44

Quel dommage que le livre n'est pas en francais! Sounds as if there was quite a lot of it actually, even after the cuts were made. Sounds like a fascinating description of post-war Paris and of the US in the 1950s, which was not actually paradise - shock/choc! Many thanks for an interesting and balanced review.

Manang Muyang · Post by **Manang Muyang** » 10 Nov 2018, 17:44

sonya01 wrote: ↑09 Nov 2018, 02:53 Somehow from reading your review, I am drawn to reading this book. I think it has something to do with the whimsical feel it has of a boy growing up far from home, and tackling all these new challenges in a humorous way. The time setting is also one that appeals to me, when things weren’t so dark and shadowy. Lovely review. Well done!

Yep, I liked the innocence and credulity of Jeanot. Thanks for the lovely comment!