Page 1 of 1

Review of Fourth Sister

Posted: 27 Jun 2021, 14:35
by mmm17
[Following is an official OnlineBookClub.org review of "Fourth Sister" by M. L. Farb.]
Book Cover
4 out of 4 stars
Share This Review


Myrtle and many others gather to hear a tale told by a bard wearing a white fox mask at the beginning of Fourth Sister: Hearth and Bard Tales, written by M.L. Farb. It takes place in Nihon, a land full of powerful spirits (kami). The story pulls elements from Japanese age-old beliefs, traditions, and culture, creating a spellbinding tale.

Shisei, the protagonist, is the fourth of seven sisters; we follow her journey from desperation, fear, and death to spiritual awakening, courage, and life. Shisei feels guilty because her twin brother died at birth. She prays to a deity (Inari) to give her another brother, but her mother dies during childbirth. The protagonist and her sisters believe that Shisei carries a curse against unborn sons. Grieving and feeling she is cursed, she decides to wander from village to village to find an apprenticeship. She does this disguised as a boy, assuming her deceased twin’s name – Sheng. Takumi, a mask maker, receives Shisei as an apprentice, and the journey begins.

I very much enjoyed reading this book, and it had numerous positive aspects. What I liked the most was its deeply touching symbolism. For instance, Shisei’s name is full of meaning; her mother told her it meant sacred poetry, a bridge between the seen and unseen. Also, “shi” is a word that means both fourth and death.

Additionally, the plot itself is full of parables and metaphors. Initially, the protagonist thinks a white fox full of tricks is making her life miserable and persecuting her. She feels she has a demon following her and causing harm. Shisei is markedly afraid of tricksters, but in a paradoxical move, she decides to hide her identity to seek knowledge. Above all, the author skillfully explores the metaphor of mask making; Shisei has the skill of illusion, which she strives to understand and master throughout the story, just as she struggles to learn how to make masks in her apprenticeship.

I also enjoyed the Japanese elements in the story. There are tatamis, kimonos, sacred poetry (haikus), tea ceremonies, Japanese theater, music, and dance. Readers learn about the spirits, gods, and deities of Japan’s Shinto religion. They make for a mystical background, which I appreciated. The book is poetic and artistic; the sisters’ different talents and skills combine to create a united front to defeat the fears and threats they face.

In closing, I’m glad to rate this lovely book 4 out of 4 stars. It seemed professionally edited; I found no editing mistakes in it. I see no negative aspects either. It is an exquisite tale of hope and redemption, and I recommend it to those who enjoy fantasy and symbolism. Also, if you appreciate Japanese culture, you should take a look at it.

******
Fourth Sister
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon

Re: Review of Fourth Sister

Posted: 29 Jun 2021, 02:09
by Kavita Shah
The cursed sister and her journey from fear to courage sounds really good. I would like to read this story to know a bit more about Japanese culture. Thank you for a great review!

Re: Review of Fourth Sister

Posted: 29 Jun 2021, 10:17
by Amy Luman
I like Japanese culture. I hope this book will get into it a little. I will read it for sure!

Re: Review of Fourth Sister

Posted: 29 Jun 2021, 13:30
by Kristy Khem
This sounds like a thrilling tale. I would love to read about Shisei's journey. Cross-dressing seems to be popular in Asian films now; it seems that this extends to Asian fiction too. The mystical Japanese background seems like a great backdrop for this story. Excellent review - it makes me want to read this book!

Re: Review of Fourth Sister

Posted: 29 Jun 2021, 15:24
by The frant1c reader
I've always been drawn to the Japanese culture. History, folktales and art alike. Liked the theme and would give it a try. Thanks for such a well written review! :D

Re: Review of Fourth Sister

Posted: 04 Jul 2021, 08:13
by Scofield K
I have alway read Japanese culture i want to get the part that gives more attention to the book instead of only telling as the curse let them tell us were the curse came from but the book is very nice

Re: Review of Fourth Sister

Posted: 06 Jul 2021, 06:52
by NetMassimo
I'm not sure I know enough of Japanese culture to fully appreciate the symbolism but this novel seems fascinating in all its references. Thank you for your great review!

Re: Review of Fourth Sister

Posted: 17 Jul 2021, 17:26
by Amanda Dobson
This sounds like my kind of book! The symbolism in Japanese culture and the understanding of where the fourth sister is coming from is an addition to the novel that makes it more fulfilled. Thanks for the awesome review.

Re: Review of Fourth Sister

Posted: 21 Jul 2021, 19:50
by Black Jewel
This sounds like an interesting insight into Japanese culture. I might have to look into it one of these days. Thank you for the terrific review.

Re: Review of Fourth Sister

Posted: 22 Jul 2021, 08:30
by DTamara
That sounds fascinating, sort of a fable, I would love to read something with more insight into the Japanese culture. Would you say it is suitable for a younger public as well? Since you didn't mention anything contradictory, I suppose so.