OnlineBookClub.org

In my opinion, Mr. Seoh did the best that he could do to ensure that his family’s needs are satisfied and at the same time take part, even in the smallest way such as giving financial assistance, to the cause. Being a Korean, there is no question that he wanted independence but thinking about actions in the long-term, he did what he has to do for the responsibilities as a husband and a father.

I certainly understand his choice and decisions. He simply wanted to join the movement, but cannot afford risking his family and job. It's not one I would have made, nonetheless. I prefer a sure footed stand. You're either for or against.

I think the resistance was a double edged sword for Mr. Seoh . On one hand he had to consider his growing family with a new baby on the way. If he had joined the resistance openly his family would have been lost without his support. On the other hand he also had to consider his new position in the bank. Joining the resistance for sure would cost him all he has worked hard for. Hence making the tough decision he managed to still contribute albeit in small and discreet way.

I believe in his heart, Mr. Seoh wanted to actively fight for the independence of Korea, but he had a young family and they were depending on him to provide for them. His first responsibility was for his family. It would not have been fair to them for Mr. Seoh to risk his life or his occupation to stand up and declare himself a freedom fighter. Life is very complicated but family is always first.

I think Mr Seoh did his best under the circumstances. Openly fighting against the Japanese would have jeopardized his family. It's not something someone can judge unless they are in those shoes.

I do think Mr. Seoh made the right decision for his particular situation. He had so much riding on his shoulders and income, like providing food for his family. I know for me personally it would be hard to see my family suffer because of my choices. I think he did well by sucking up his pride and keeping his employment at the Japanese bank.

Bookishkrish24 wrote: ↑14 Jan 2021, 09:28 I think there are many layers to this question. As many said, Mr.seoh was engulfed by guilt. And that's why he did help them financially but within his comfort zone, without risking his job. At the same time, in the long run, dedicated professionals like him are essential for the country once they are independent.

Yes, he was torn in two directions. He believed in the cause, but he also wanted to protect his family and keep his job. So, I agree it was probably at least a little bit of guilt that inspired him to help financially. However, I believe if he had not had the added responsibility of his wife expecting another child he would have fought with his countrymen!

Pearl Hijabi wrote: ↑15 Jan 2021, 03:07 I think the resistance was a double edged sword for Mr. Seoh . On one hand he had to consider his growing family with a new baby on the way. If he had joined the resistance openly his family would have been lost without his support. On the other hand he also had to consider his new position in the bank. Joining the resistance for sure would cost him all he has worked hard for. Hence making the tough decision he managed to still contribute albeit in small and discreet way.

Exactly! I guess you could say in essence he made it work both ways, with contributions to the cause of the resistance while being available to his family, and also keeping his job!

Twylla wrote: ↑15 Jan 2021, 13:42 I believe in his heart, Mr. Seoh wanted to actively fight for the independence of Korea, but he had a young family and they were depending on him to provide for them. His first responsibility was for his family. It would not have been fair to them for Mr. Seoh to risk his life or his occupation to stand up and declare himself a freedom fighter. Life is very complicated but family is always first.

Yes, I agree family is first. I think he did the only thing a caring husband and father would have done, and that is to make sure his family remained safe and well taken care of. He contributed in his own way for the best to both sides— family and the resistance.

This is a very good question to dwell upon. If seeing from Mr. Seoh's side, being loyal to Japanese employer provided it keeps the family from poverty and hunger is not a bad choice. People have to think about their families too. Its not bad to demand a comfortable life. But some deed done by the Japanese like killing Korean rulers and trying to remove their culture and heritage was not good at all. All of this demands in itself a revolt which cannot be prevented. The fight for independence is in much need at this point of time.
Speaking of myself, I would fight for the independence of the country but at the same time would assemble resources to feed my family and not neglecting them completely.

Honestly, Mr. Seoh's position was very tenuous. How to choose between country and family! Although it is easy to say that he should have joined his friend in the fight against the Japanese occupation, the reality is the fight needed funding and persons who worked for the Japanese who could provide insider information. Mr. Seoh supplied whatever finance and support he could. He chose to act behind the scenes, rather than be at the forefront of the fight. It is my view that his decision cannot be easily judged by one on the outside looking in. Those in the midst of the struggle had to be led by their conscience.

I think it's difficult to choose resistance over employment especially when livelihood is at stake. I think that it's important to consider that a lot of Koreans did weigh their options and realised that the risk was not worth the reward.

I found Mr. Seoh weak, but if I think about this deeply. Not everybody is able to fight or give up their comfort, I think some people are just meant to be support crew. At least Mr. seoh always fed and gave Mr. Koo some money each time he passed by.

He could have joined Mr. Koo, but he gives priority for his family and job.

I think it's a win-win situation. He needs his job and his privilege to keep his family safe. The resistance also profits from his choice by receiving the money he earns from the Japanese employer. There are different ways to fight, and one doesn't need to risk his life for his actions to count.