Review of Memoir of a closet christian

[Magdalyne chebet]

"Memoir of a Closet Christian" by Roy Warren sounds like a compelling read, offering a unique and personal perspective on Christianity. The author's honesty about his flaws and his journey to faith, along with the discussion of "Pistis Sophia," are intriguing elements. I'm interested in exploring how his life experiences and studies shaped his spiritual path. Thank you for the great review!

[Annabell Samuel]

I find the title of the book interesting. It carries a promise of making Christianity understandable to the reader right down to where they are. I can't wait to dive deeper into it.

[Chi Chiu Michael Mak]

[Following is an official OnlineBookClub.org review of "Memoir of a closet christian" by Roy Warren.]

---

2 out of 4 stars

---

Share This Review

---

Memoir of a Closet Christian by Roy Warren is, as the name makes clear, a book about Christianity. The book does not approach the Christian religion historically or philosophically but in a more simplistic way. In addition to recounting various aspects of his life that made him genuinely become a Christian, there is an emphasis on the discussion of the book Pistis Sophia, which, according to the author, played a vital role in helping him find "his truth."

The author considers his work a "teaching guide about getting into heaven." It has three parts: a biographical part, another one focused on the most diverse Christian teachings, and the conclusion. There are also some photos of the author and his family members.

The book has some interesting aspects. In addition to mentioning and discussing several books, the author explains how his conversion to Christianity occurred. When he was very young, Roy went to church to "steal" the money he asked his mother for tithing. Later, he started studying religious content to impress a girl. However, as time passed, faith began to well up in his heart. Even so, when he was an adult, he had to hide his religion to avoid social isolation. I have never read a book written by a Christian in which the author is so open about his flaws. That's what I liked the most about this work.

At the end of the book, the author clarifies what any attentive reader realized from the beginning: that Roy Warren is not a professional writer. So far, no big deal, because you don't need to make a living from writing books. The problem is that this book desperately needs another round of editing. There are many grammatical errors, and the author ignores the concept of page breaks. Halfway through the book, the author discusses the book Pistis Sophia and, out of the blue, stops to talk about the life of Edgar Casey. After some pages, he goes back to discussing the rest of the chapters. All these defects significantly damaged the message to be conveyed.

Memoir of a Closet Christian is the classic case of a sound idea not so well executed. While I loved reading about his personal life and how the author had to repress his faith to avoid social conflicts, the editing flaws outweigh the positive aspects. That's why I had to deduct two stars from the final score. Therefore, I rate this book two out of four stars. After another round of editing, this book has what it takes to become a classic and touch many people's hearts. This book is for you if you don't mind grammatical errors (plus editing flaws) and would like to read about Christianity through a more unorthodox approach.

******
Memoir of a closet christian
View: on Bookshelves

An honest take on the book's strengths and flaws. Thoughts can be messy and disorganized, so good editing is paramount so readers can get a clear understanding of the message and empathize with the characters' situations. Still, congratulations for winning Book of the Day!

[Tomi Ahmed]

"Memoir of a Closet Christian" by Roy Warren is a candid exploration of the author's journey to Christianity, influenced by the Pistis Sophia. The book's strengths lie in its openness and unique narrative, including Warren's unconventional path to faith and his struggle to hide his beliefs to avoid social isolation. However, significant editing issues, such as grammatical errors and poor organization, detract from its overall impact. Despite these flaws, the memoir's sincerity may still appeal to readers. With further editing, it could become a heartfelt classic. Currently, it earns two out of four stars.

[Dave Mbk]

Le commentaire de "Mémoires d'un chrétien de placard" met en lumière la sincérité et l'authenticité de l'auteur dans son exploration du christianisme. Toutefois, il souligne également les nombreux défauts d'édition, tels que les erreurs grammaticales et la structure désorganisée, qui affaiblissent le message de l'ouvrage. L'avis du critique est équilibré, reconnaissant la valeur personnelle de l'histoire tout en appelant à une révision approfondie pour en améliorer la clarté et l'impact. Cela reflète une appréciation honnête de l'œuvre, avec des recommandations constructives pour son amélioration future.

[Hamsapriya Krishnamurthy]

That's a honest review! I was skeptical that this book is completely for Christians based on the title of the book. After sampling, I confirmed it to be true. I could see author's desperate efforts to bring the community as one and to bring them to Church visit regularly to keep up the spirit of Christianity. Congrats for the BOTD!

[Ukaegbu Confidence]

Memoir of a Closet Christian by Roy Warren is a Christian book that relays Christianity in a simple, easy-to-understand way. The author speaks of his personal experience and how he became a Christian.

[Jorge Leon Salazar]

I find the prospect of a book about Christianity in which the author went through that conversion process attractive. I'm curious to read what things he did to hide his religion so as not to isolate himself socially. The author's approach of being open about his flaws sounds appealing for a religious book.

[María Andrea Fernández Sepúlveda]

I'm not sure the story would be so compelling if it were just about the teachings, but I do feel curious about the social circumstances that led the author to hide his religious beliefs. It strikes me as odd unless one lives in some oppressive regime. I hope the book gets a second editing round. Thank you for your review.

[Seetha E]

Roy's story is an intriguing read. Unfortunately, the book was scored low due to errors and editing concerns. I hope the author accepts your suggestion. For the time being, I've put it on my TBR list. I'd like to give it another shot later. Thanks for an insightful review.

[Pablo Josue Mendia]

Thank you for your informative review!

"Memoir of a Closet Christian" by Roy Warren clearly seems like an honest and personal account of the author's faith journey. However, the editing issues seem significant. The book's interesting aspects, like the author's conversion to Christianity seem worth reading. Congrats #BOTD

[Abhishek3m4]

This review of *Memoir of a Closet Christian* by Roy Warren highlights the book's candid exploration of personal faith and the influence of *Pistis Sophia* on the author's spiritual journey. While the review appreciates the author's openness about his flaws and the engaging biographical content, it critiques the book's significant editing issues, including grammatical errors and disorganized content. Despite these flaws, the review suggests the book has potential to resonate deeply with readers if revised, ultimately rating it two out of four stars.

[Sushan Ekanayake]

"Memoir of a Closet Christian" by Roy Warren explores personal struggles with faith and the journey to embracing Christianity. The candid storytelling is refreshing. Definitely sounds like a raw and honest read. Congratulations on being BOTD!

[Hugo Vee]

This review aptly describes "Memoir of a closet christian" by Roy Warren. After reading some chapters of this book, my synopsis is that it is a guidebook on how to make Heaven that is heavily inspired by Gnostic teachings and personal experiences.

[Ajiferuke Ajibola]

A book that takes a straightforward approach to Christianity is beneficial to all people. It will, I firmly believe, teach a great number of people the truth about Christianity. The author even went so far as to demonstrate his humanity, which is why I adore it even more. Congratulations on BOTD. Well-written review.