Review by bogdan isaev -- The New Eugenics
-
bogdan isaev
- Posts: 1
- Joined: 04 Apr 2021, 05:49
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 0
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-bogdan-isaev.html
- Latest Review: The New Eugenics by Conrad B. Quintyn
Review by bogdan isaev -- The New Eugenics
[Following is a volunteer review of "The New Eugenics" by Conrad B. Quintyn.]
The New Eugenics by Conrad B. Quintyn is a blend of historical achievement, the moral and logistical dilemmas behind these achievements and an analysis of scientists' attitudes towards advanced technology. Quintyn begins by defining the term, and namesake of the book, "The New Eugenics", and proceeds to describe the existing technologies capable of changing the code of life (DNA), and showing that such technology has already been applied - giving examples such as Dolly the sheep. The book is divided between historical narration and explanation of how gene-editing technologies were discovered, and the author's commentary on the risks these technologies pose for the organisms on earth, including humans.
Something I greatly enjoyed whilst reading was the plentiful use of sources, studies and quotes taken from biologists and public figures. These helped to provide examples for each topic, and showed the attitudes of scientists who handle this dangerous technology - it is clear to see just how much research was done for this book. Additionally, the author provides many interesting perspectives and arguments which successfully provoke the reader into thinking (and coming up with their own judgment) about the issues discussed. Lastly, I found Quintyn's tone very fun to read, as he consistently comments on what other's have said and done, pointing out the irony in their actions, making for an overall pleasurable read.
On the other hand, a few elements detract from the overall experience. Notably, I felt that some explanations (such as those associated with 'CRISPR') were explained in too much detail, making it hard to understand and drawn out; though some readers may enjoy the in-depth explanation. It should also be mentioned that a lot of jargon is used, so readers who aren't versed in cellular biology will find themselves often flipping to the glossary (or the internet) to look up terms, as I found myself doing.
I rate this book 4 out of 4 stars as it very successfully outlines advancements in biotechnology and argues the fine line between their risks and benefits. The topics are intriguing and interesting to read, as well as clearly well-researched. Though some grammatical mistakes occur, they are sparse and do not detract from meaning.
I would recommend this book to anyone interested in biology, and interested in the potential applications of genetic engineering - especially if you have a basic knowledge of the workings of a cell, as it will help to widen your knowledge and contextualize what you know. Even for readers who don't have previous knowledge, the book contains a glossary of key definitions, and aims to make the debate on uses of bioengineering accessible to all readers.
******
The New Eugenics
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon
The New Eugenics by Conrad B. Quintyn is a blend of historical achievement, the moral and logistical dilemmas behind these achievements and an analysis of scientists' attitudes towards advanced technology. Quintyn begins by defining the term, and namesake of the book, "The New Eugenics", and proceeds to describe the existing technologies capable of changing the code of life (DNA), and showing that such technology has already been applied - giving examples such as Dolly the sheep. The book is divided between historical narration and explanation of how gene-editing technologies were discovered, and the author's commentary on the risks these technologies pose for the organisms on earth, including humans.
Something I greatly enjoyed whilst reading was the plentiful use of sources, studies and quotes taken from biologists and public figures. These helped to provide examples for each topic, and showed the attitudes of scientists who handle this dangerous technology - it is clear to see just how much research was done for this book. Additionally, the author provides many interesting perspectives and arguments which successfully provoke the reader into thinking (and coming up with their own judgment) about the issues discussed. Lastly, I found Quintyn's tone very fun to read, as he consistently comments on what other's have said and done, pointing out the irony in their actions, making for an overall pleasurable read.
On the other hand, a few elements detract from the overall experience. Notably, I felt that some explanations (such as those associated with 'CRISPR') were explained in too much detail, making it hard to understand and drawn out; though some readers may enjoy the in-depth explanation. It should also be mentioned that a lot of jargon is used, so readers who aren't versed in cellular biology will find themselves often flipping to the glossary (or the internet) to look up terms, as I found myself doing.
I rate this book 4 out of 4 stars as it very successfully outlines advancements in biotechnology and argues the fine line between their risks and benefits. The topics are intriguing and interesting to read, as well as clearly well-researched. Though some grammatical mistakes occur, they are sparse and do not detract from meaning.
I would recommend this book to anyone interested in biology, and interested in the potential applications of genetic engineering - especially if you have a basic knowledge of the workings of a cell, as it will help to widen your knowledge and contextualize what you know. Even for readers who don't have previous knowledge, the book contains a glossary of key definitions, and aims to make the debate on uses of bioengineering accessible to all readers.
******
The New Eugenics
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon
Latest Review: The New Eugenics by Conrad B. Quintyn
