Review of Exceptions to Their Rule
-
chineye Nwaigwe
- Posts: 33
- Joined: 29 Sep 2023, 12:34
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 27
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-chineye-nwaigwe.html
- Latest Review: The Fox by M. N. J. Butler
Review of Exceptions to Their Rule
[Following is a volunteer review of "Exceptions to Their Rule" by Richard S. Sloan.]
Exceptions to Their Rule by Richard S. Sloan delves into the interactions and dynamics between two unique cultures, the Wabanaki and the Basque, across a period spanning from the 13th to the 16th centuries. Within its pages, the author intricately explores their trading traditions, democratic practices, cosmologies, and encounters with autocratic powers. The book prompts reflection on the repercussions of these interactions, challenges the exceptionalism associated with these cultures, and scrutinizes the historical narratives encompassing them. Moreover, it delves into themes of colonialism, indigenous perspectives, and the intricate complexities inherent in understanding and interpreting historical events.
One of the reasons I love this book is how it skillfully incorporates and delves into the works of esteemed historians like Wendy Childs from the University of Leeds, Bruce Bourque, Steven Cox, Laurier Turgeon, Samantha Brannen, John Campbell, and Ihintza Marguirault. Their significant contributions in their respective fields of study have undeniably enriched the book's depth and comprehensive coverage, adding a layer of academic rigour and insight that truly elevates the reading experience for me.
Their meticulous research and scholarly expertise shine through, making this book an invaluable resource that captivates and educates readers with a multifaceted exploration of historical perspectives. I'd recommend this book to history enthusiasts, academics, and those intrigued by cultural interactions across different periods.
What I disliked about this book was its heavy focus on exploring questions and potential rather than offering a predetermined or formulaic plot. The author admitted to starting the research with questions, and despite years of exploration, their ignorance remained largely unchanged. For my taste, the book prioritized exploration and contemplation over a structured, predictable narrative, which made it less enjoyable for me. The book was exceptionally well-edited and error-free.
I gave this book a rating of 5 out of 5 stars. What truly stands out is its remarkable dive into the intricate interactions between the Wabanaki and Basque cultures across several centuries. Sloan skillfully navigates the historical landscape, meticulously exploring their traditions, encounters, and the nuanced aspects of their narratives. The book adeptly touches on the complexities surrounding colonialism and provides insightful glimpses into indigenous perspectives. What particularly elevates this work is the incorporation of works by esteemed historians, including Wendy Childs from the University of Leeds, Bruce Bourque, Steven Cox, and others. Their contributions significantly enrich the book's depth, lending credibility and expanding the horizons of historical analysis.
******
Exceptions to Their Rule
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon
Exceptions to Their Rule by Richard S. Sloan delves into the interactions and dynamics between two unique cultures, the Wabanaki and the Basque, across a period spanning from the 13th to the 16th centuries. Within its pages, the author intricately explores their trading traditions, democratic practices, cosmologies, and encounters with autocratic powers. The book prompts reflection on the repercussions of these interactions, challenges the exceptionalism associated with these cultures, and scrutinizes the historical narratives encompassing them. Moreover, it delves into themes of colonialism, indigenous perspectives, and the intricate complexities inherent in understanding and interpreting historical events.
One of the reasons I love this book is how it skillfully incorporates and delves into the works of esteemed historians like Wendy Childs from the University of Leeds, Bruce Bourque, Steven Cox, Laurier Turgeon, Samantha Brannen, John Campbell, and Ihintza Marguirault. Their significant contributions in their respective fields of study have undeniably enriched the book's depth and comprehensive coverage, adding a layer of academic rigour and insight that truly elevates the reading experience for me.
Their meticulous research and scholarly expertise shine through, making this book an invaluable resource that captivates and educates readers with a multifaceted exploration of historical perspectives. I'd recommend this book to history enthusiasts, academics, and those intrigued by cultural interactions across different periods.
What I disliked about this book was its heavy focus on exploring questions and potential rather than offering a predetermined or formulaic plot. The author admitted to starting the research with questions, and despite years of exploration, their ignorance remained largely unchanged. For my taste, the book prioritized exploration and contemplation over a structured, predictable narrative, which made it less enjoyable for me. The book was exceptionally well-edited and error-free.
I gave this book a rating of 5 out of 5 stars. What truly stands out is its remarkable dive into the intricate interactions between the Wabanaki and Basque cultures across several centuries. Sloan skillfully navigates the historical landscape, meticulously exploring their traditions, encounters, and the nuanced aspects of their narratives. The book adeptly touches on the complexities surrounding colonialism and provides insightful glimpses into indigenous perspectives. What particularly elevates this work is the incorporation of works by esteemed historians, including Wendy Childs from the University of Leeds, Bruce Bourque, Steven Cox, and others. Their contributions significantly enrich the book's depth, lending credibility and expanding the horizons of historical analysis.
******
Exceptions to Their Rule
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon
Latest Review: The Fox by M. N. J. Butler
