Review of America in Context: A Pursuit of the Exemplary

[Pablo Josue Mendia]

[Following is an official OnlineBookClub.org review of "America in Context: A Pursuit of the Exemplary" by Bob Dowell.]

---

4 out of 5 stars

---

Share This Review

---

America in Context: A Pursuit of the Exemplary by Bob Dowell shows us parts of America’s historical journey, focusing on its foundational vision as a “city upon a hill” (a biblical vision, creed, or dream of moving forward as a nation). The book is divided into a historical tour with eight stops. Each stop consists of a time in history, a defining event, and a “nudger” (a leader who nudges America forward in the pursuit of the exemplary). Dowell writes as if he is our historical tour guide, which balances his academic writing style and makes this book accessible to all readers.

The book starts with John Winthrop's 1630 sermon and shows us the Puritan vision of America as a biblical commonwealth. Dowell then summarizes Thomas Jefferson’s Declaration of Independence, showing the nation’s commitment to alienable rights. He also indicates Elizabeth Cady Stanton’s crucial role in the women’s rights movement through the Declaration of Sentiments.

After showing us these three “nudgers” (Winthrop, Jefferson, and Stanton), Dowell shows us five more “nudgers.” He continues with Abraham Lincoln, whose leadership "nudged" America forward during the Civil War and was marked by the Emancipation Proclamation and the Gettysburg Address in 1963. This part of the historical tour shows us how the nation aligned with the creed of equality. Dowell then moves to the civil rights era, focusing on Martin Luther King Jr.'s iconic "I Have a Dream" speech, which led to the Civil Rights Act of 1964.

The book also covers Ronald Reagan's efforts in the 1980s to restore America's image and George W. Bush's call for national unity. Dowell’s eighth chapter leads us to the present, encouraging all Americans to be the “nudgers” who will move the country forward and uphold the nation’s exemplary vision. In short, Dowell shows us how Winthrop, Jefferson, Stanton, Lincoln, King Jr., Raegan, and Bush were exemplary “nudgers” who should inspire Americans in the present to “nudge” forward collectively.

I like that the book contains footnotes and references from other textbooks, which gives it depth and credibility. I like that the book offers many thought-provoking questions, allowing introspective readers to deeply reflect on the past, present, and future of America.

I deducted a star, however, because the book’s arguments are narrow-minded. I like historical accounts that give us both sides of the picture. However, this historical guide presents data to support the claim that the only way to move forward as a nation is through a Christian doctrine, and the country will falter without Christian values and principles. It does not consider that non-Christians and non-religious groups can lead the country forward. In addition, the book seems to glorify figures that not all Christian Americans would consider “nudgers,” such as George W. Bush. For these reasons, I rate it 4 out of 5 stars.

Despite its possible drawbacks, I recommend the book to Christians who want a Christian-based America in the future. I also recommend it to those who wish to learn about the connection between patriotic leaders and their incorporation of biblical creeds. Lastly, I recommend it to those who can look past the narrow-scope of this book and appreciate its valuable insights and connections.

******
America in Context: A Pursuit of the Exemplary
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon

[Anthony Caleb]

Reading this review is making me want to grab this book immediately, I so much love books that speaks about history.

[Yin Jiang]

This sounds like an interesting book. I enjoyed your critique, particularly your point about the narrow-mindedness of the book. I might pick this up for myself! Thank you for your review.

[Martin Shae]

America in Context: A Pursuit of the Exemplary by Bob Dowell explores America's historical journey, focusing on its foundational vision as a "city upon a hill." Divided into eight historical stops, each with a defining event and a leader who nudges America forward, Dowell's writing balances an academic style with a tour guide's accessibility, making the book engaging for all readers.

[Boring Pigeon]

As an AI language model, I don't have a personal accent. However, based on the review provided, it seems like "America in Context: A Pursuit of the Exemplary" by Bob Dowell could be an interesting read for those interested in America's historical journey and its connection to Christian values. The book provides a historical tour, highlighting significant events and influential leaders who moved the nation forward. It offers thought-provoking questions and references from other textbooks, adding credibility to its content. However, one drawback mentioned is the book's narrow-minded perspective, focusing solely on Christian doctrine and figures. Considering this, I would rate the book 4 out of 5 stars. Overall, it appears to be a good read for those interested in exploring America's history through a Christian lens. Profound insights, left me pondering deeply.

[Elavarasi Charles]

Thank you for your honest review. This book looks to awaken the collective interest of the Americans in their patriotism which is an admirable and selfless vision. Doing it by bringing forth the ideals of historically important figures is a powerful idea as it easily connects the population and brings the common well-being to the forefront. Also, as you said, marking a certain religion, race, or any aspect for that matter to be the overpowering doctrine might be a diffuser of what the book aims to achieve. Adaptability and inclusivity are inevitable factors in modern patriotism. Your review nicely summarises all the key points. Great job!