High School Appropriate - Yes or No

[Shirley Ann Riddern Labzentis]

First of all, I disagree with the word "crap" being a profane word. I read the book, and I didn't think there was any sexual content in it at all. I think that this is a perfect read for high schoolers. Believe me, they read and talk much worse then what is in this book. I thought that the book was very clean and suitable for young adults. I guess the editors feel differently. My review was just submitted, so it seems that it will be rejected. Oh, well. You can't win them all!

[Zippy Kerubo]

This teenager of nowadays are exposed to a lot of many things that even old people wouldn't believe of. This all is about school teaching

[Sarah Zain]

It's right that teens are exposed to many things and have more knowledge than an older generation, but this doesn't mean that it's a green card to expose them to more stuff.
What I liked the most about the book was that the author discussed the issues in a sensitive way without giving explicit details. Crap as a word is profane, even if it's usually said, especially if the book is read not only by teens but by other audiences who will appreciate marking the word.

[Cathryn Gorlinsky]

I think this would be an appropriate read for teens. I appreciate that it doesn’t romanticize suicide, and I like the realistic representation of social anxiety. I believe normalizing discussions about difficult topics prevents a lot of mental strife later down the road because these topics shouldn’t be taboo or shame-inducing.

[Rocky Ellery James Tumbelaka]

Definitely. This book taught a lot of important things for youth, especially high schooler. A point where children began transitioning and feeling a miriad of emotions. I like the fact that the book teaches about kindness. That a single act of kindness could change a life. Instead of selfishly went on our own day, we should care more for others, because we would never know what struggles are they facing. I believe that is an important lesson that high schooler need to know as they went to adulthood.

[Carly Sprout]

A high school classroom could benefit from reading it. The book promotes important discussions about mental health and suicide. Teenagers have always been more prone to mental health issues, but now are even more susceptible to them. These discussions could provide a space for meaningful discussions. In addition to reducing stigma, reading it together can encourage open communication about emotions, struggles, and seeking help.

[Christopher Sublett]

I would read and discuss the content of this book with young teenagers due to the rise in the rated number of suicides in young adults across the world.
Legally, I would have to get permission granted from their parents first. The best outcome of reading this novel to the younger audience is even if only one life can be saved and spared, it was worth the explicit sexual and language context in the book.

[Abiodunakinola]

I think it will be better for high school classrooms to read this book because they will be encouraged that they are not alone and this will make them able to share their dark secrets.

[Anthony Ekemezie]

Reading this book to teenagers is good and also important because I feel as young adults they should prepare their minds for this kind of things, of which I tknow that they are already exposed. Which is why Reading it to them will help us see their different reactions and help us guide them better.

[Meghan Soderholm]

Teenagers face these issues whether high school administration or parents admit it. Therefore, the book is appropriate to read and discuss with high schoolers. Yes, some scenes in the book are a little intense to read, but they're issues that can't be ignored.

[Sonia_Gonzalez]

I think this book is ideal for high school. Teenagers are struggling with many things that adults cannot understand, or are not willing to share, and this book might help them realize what is happening or who needs a hand.

[Jnapika D]

I think it's appropriate for high schoolers, and I've got to admit that I remember my high school days so vividly that asking them not to do something is going to motivate them to do it even more. But that aside, the characters, Addison and Celia, and their struggles can help a lot of confused, depressed, and angry teenagers who are going through something similar heal and grow.

[Hyfr Zack]

Introducing this book to high school teens would be a wonderful idea. Choosing what their future holds for them is one of the difficult issues that students typically face at this stage of their lives. They would benefit greatly from this book.

[Christian_ James]

I completely agree with you. When we have the courage to address topics like suicide and depression openly in the classroom, without shying away from them, it becomes easier for people facing similar situations to open up. It also helps us recognize those who might be going through such challenges.

[Schyk Marcus]

It is appropriate to read thisin a classroom of older teenagers. They will relate to it and it will encourage them to speak up more. It is evident that the teenagers don't speak up and this in turn hinders them from getting the required help they need.