High School Appropriate - Yes or No

John Aburzzi · Post by **John Aburzzi** » 20 Sep 2023, 00:57

Yes this book would be highly helpful to teens at school... But then the relationship students has with the teachers should be okay for you to be able to know a child batting depression.

Clauson Justin · Post by **Clauson Justin** » 20 Sep 2023, 16:14

I think we live in a time where people are exposed early on even in puberty. We can't keep shying away from this fact. I think this book would be helpful to high school teens since it focuses attention on issues that need to be discussed like mental health issues and family too. It should however be edited to be suitable for them.

Post by **Olive Uche** » 21 Sep 2023, 02:47

Yes, the profanity and sexual content can be restricted if there is a problem. Since so many children experience sadness, bullying, abuse of many kinds, etc., I think this book is essential for drawing their attention and, in a manner, letting them know they aren't alone and that there are solutions.

Rishaunda Lynnette Britton · 21 Sep 2023, 07:24

That might be a good idea. But then they have to be sure they are disposed for that. On the other issues, it's unfortunate you review got rejected. I hope you've noted the mistakes. Good luck.

Bettny Andrade · Post by **Bettny Andrade** » 22 Sep 2023, 04:15

I have realized that some words, which for me do not represent any type of blasphemy, in the PRQ do consider it and special detail must be taken.

I think that any kind of support, that indicates in some way how to approach certain delicate topics, or that in some way provides a testimony that can benefit someone else, is good to share, whether in a classroom or in an everyday conversation.

Post by **Amanda Nixon** » 24 Sep 2023, 12:54

The issue with the logic from some people that a book covering this content isn't appropriate for a classroom is that it's because they think the students are too young to be subjected to these issues. But the truth is that kids go through these things and need to be taught that they're not alone and shown ways they can receive and be given help. Mental health, suicide, family issues. They're very prevalent among high schoolers and to shut it out as if it's not just makes the problem worse. I'd rather learn about it in high school, then be blindsided in later life when finding myself unable to cope with, say, depression because everyone acted like it didn't exist in high school because they thought it was too "inappropriate" and our ever fragile minds couldn't handle it. The truth is life is uncomfortable and talking about it helps us find ways to enjoy it. Just saying

Malthide Jones · Post by **Malthide Jones** » 28 Sep 2023, 04:09

I think that the book is appropriate for High schoolers. It shows them that they are not alone. It als helps them to accept the natural conditions.

Post by **Abril Zacca** » 29 Sep 2023, 08:43

I believe it could be beneficial to utilize this book in a classroom setting to stimulate discussions about the subjects mentioned in it. Additionally, it may be helpful to offer students a way to express their thoughts without revealing their identities, so they feel free to share without fear of judgment.

Post by **Dalia Chf** » 29 Sep 2023, 13:32

I feel like this book should be read ESPECIALLY to teenagers. It deals with such important topics in such a delicate way that it's one of the best books to read to teenagers. I get that it isn't 100% pure, but that's life, and nowadays teenagers have seen and lived things that are far more important than the word "crap".

Alicia Tickler · Post by **Alicia Tickler** » 29 Sep 2023, 17:21

Nancy004 wrote: ↑18 Jul 2023, 11:43 I think it's a great idea to introduce this book in high school because it helps students become more aware of important topics like suicide, family issues, abuse, and mental health problems like depression and anxiety. Many students in high school might be going through these things themselves, and having open discussions about them in the classroom can make them feel safe to share their experiences and seek support. By addressing these subjects in school, we can contribute to creating a society that values and prioritizes everyone's mental well-being.

I absolutely agree with you. These issues certainly weren't discussed when I was high school 10-15 years ago. I think it helps to turn these experiences into a narrative that kids can relate to, or even adopt if they are not yet comfortable disclosing personal issues.

Chimezie Agbata · Post by **Chimezie Agbata** » 29 Sep 2023, 22:59

It would be a great idea to read this book with teenagers. Growing up there have been so much pressure from school, to make mama and papa proud, social media, friend, younger sibling, sometimes I feel so lost and depressed. This book evinces so much reality and discuss topics that are relevant to an average teen. It would be quite an interesting read for them.

Chigozie Anuli Mbadugha · Post by **Chigozie Anuli Mbadugha** » 05 Oct 2023, 21:37

The subject matter of depression and suicide is something that affects teenagers and sadly, a lot of times, they are not able to talk about it and seek counsel. So for me, it is a yes. One can provide anonymity to them to talk. I did that at a school book reading once and it was humbling. While I couldn't ask the writer of the note I got to step out, I did ask her to seek urgent counsel and the school promised to follow up.

Buikem Kasia · Post by **Buikem Kasia** » 09 Oct 2023, 00:10

It is appropriate for high schoolers. In fact, this book relates to them more than any other age group. They should learn to speak up when they are feeling down.

Brandon Sanderson · Post by **Marie Chalupová** » 09 Oct 2023, 16:15

I don't think it's only appropriate I think it should be required read. It really goes through a lot of different issues teenagers can have and shows how there is always hope and that there are people who are willing to help, just that sometimes you have to take the first step and ask for help.

Nele Ma · Post by **Nele Ma** » 11 Oct 2023, 07:07

Introducing this book in high school is a great idea. It covers essential topics like suicide, family issues, and mental health, which many students may relate to. It can create a safe space for discussions and provide support for those in need. I agree that addressing these topics openly can make a significant difference, and this book is suitable for young teens. It's crucial for high schoolers to have access to such material, as it can provide the necessary support and guidance, and censoring rarely works with teenagers.