To both Americans and a non-Americans: which of Ali's experiences surprised you the most?

[Gee-Q Mdluli]

To both Americans and a non-Americans: which of Ali's experiences surprised you the most?

[Cristina-Ioana Toader]

One aspect of the author's journey that profoundly moved me was the intense emotional turmoil he endured after embracing Christianity upon his return to Karachi. In Pakistan, where religious conversion can be met with social pressure and familial distress, his experience was particularly harrowing.
His conversion led to his parents being judged and ostracized, causing them to reproach him, but this was deeply painful for the author. The distress was palpable in his parents; his father fell severely ill with fever, a physical manifestation of his anguish, while his mother's accusations were cutting: "This is your doing. If he dies, it's your fault." In a desperate attempt to address the situation, his family even resorted to admitting him to a psychiatric hospital, hoping a diagnosis of mental instability might explain his conversion.
The emotional burden was almost too much to bear. Upon moving back to Texas, the ordeal didn't end; his father's letters, twenty pages filled with sorrow and blame, continued to arrive, each one a testament to the lasting emotional scars left by these resulting challenges. This was both disturbing and deeply touching simultaneously.

[Carol McCoy Phelps]

One aspect of the author's journey that profoundly moved me was the intense emotional turmoil he endured after embracing Christianity upon his return to Karachi. In Pakistan, where religious conversion can be met with social pressure and familial distress, his experience was particularly harrowing.
His conversion led to his parents being judged and ostracized, causing them to reproach him, but this was deeply painful for the author. The distress was palpable in his parents; his father fell severely ill with fever, a physical manifestation of his anguish, while his mother's accusations were cutting: "This is your doing. If he dies, it's your fault." In a desperate attempt to address the situation, his family even resorted to admitting him to a psychiatric hospital, hoping a diagnosis of mental instability might explain his conversion.
The emotional burden was almost too much to bear. Upon moving back to Texas, the ordeal didn't end; his father's letters, twenty pages filled with sorrow and blame, continued to arrive, each one a testament to the lasting emotional scars left by these resulting challenges. This was both disturbing and deeply touching simultaneously.

Can you just imagine your mother putting that kind of guilt trip on you? It’s the fodder of nightmares! I have to wonder if it is a cultural norm for families to react so dramatically, or, rather, overreact from our perspective. It certainly could be a way to control behavior for a person of less resolve and stamina. My own father tried similar tactics with me when I married someone of whom he disapproved, so I understand how much pain can be inflicted. However, it didn’t go anywhere near this far. You are so right about it being disturbing and touching.

I wonder how other immigrants deal with their families when they assimilate into new cultures and new religions. Possibly much the same? My own parents might have lost their minds had I converted to anything outside our Christian religion, come to think of it. To them, it would signal eternal damnation. I am sure the author’s family (and any other family) might also feel shamed within their communities, and within their religious congregations especially. Still, to put that much pressure upon their own son seems beyond anything I could do.

My daughter married a Taoist. I am not bothered by that. Would you be? After reading this book, and writing this insightful response to the forum question, how do you think you might react if you had a child who converted to a different religion?

[Cristina-Ioana Toader]

Can you just imagine your mother putting that kind of guilt trip on you? It’s the fodder of nightmares! I have to wonder if it is a cultural norm for families to react so dramatically, or, rather, overreact from our perspective. It certainly could be a way to control behavior for a person of less resolve and stamina. My own father tried similar tactics with me when I married someone of whom he disapproved, so I understand how much pain can be inflicted. However, it didn’t go anywhere near this far. You are so right about it being disturbing and touching.

I wonder how other immigrants deal with their families when they assimilate into new cultures and new religions. Possibly much the same? My own parents might have lost their minds had I converted to anything outside our Christian religion, come to think of it. To them, it would signal eternal damnation. I am sure the author’s family (and any other family) might also feel shamed within their communities, and within their religious congregations especially. Still, to put that much pressure upon their own son seems beyond anything I could do.

My daughter married a Taoist. I am not bothered by that. Would you be? After reading this book, and writing this insightful response to the forum question, how do you think you might react if you had a child who converted to a different religion?

It seems to me that cultural context plays a significant role in shaping our perspectives, particularly regarding religion. Coming from Europe, where religious indoctrination is less prevalent than in previous generations, I`ve been granted the freedom to choose my beliefs from an early age. As for myself, I intend to be even more open-minded with my child; I aim to offer him the same latitude of choice. Like the author of the book, we all view the world through our unique cultural lenses, just as our parents did through theirs.

I sympathize with the difficulties you've faced with your father. Sometimes, it seems parents exert control over their children out of a misguided sense of love, not realizing the full impact of their actions. As for the topic of religious conversion, I've been fortunate to have supportive parents throughout my life. While my father is quite conservative, I don't believe their reaction to any religious transition I might undertake would be as severe as what the author experienced.

In raising my own child, my highest priority is to support him in every way possible. My personal beliefs should not impede his happiness and well-being. If he feels safe, happy, fulfilled, and at peace, then I am satisfied. These ideals may seem idyllic on paper, and it's one thing to state them now, but I sincerely hope that if, in 15-20 years, my son decides to change his religion, I will stand firm in my current beliefs and support him wholeheartedly.
Is your daughter content? Is she secure and cherished? If the answer is affirmative, then you've succeeded in accepting your child's decisions and placing your trust in her.

[Shanesha Sammerson]

Can you just imagine your mother putting that kind of guilt trip on you? It’s the fodder of nightmares! I have to wonder if it is a cultural norm for families to react so dramatically, or, rather, overreact from our perspective. It certainly could be a way to control behavior for a person of less resolve and stamina. My own father tried similar tactics with me when I married someone of whom he disapproved, so I understand how much pain can be inflicted. However, it didn’t go anywhere near this far. You are so right about it being disturbing and touching.

I wonder how other immigrants deal with their families when they assimilate into new cultures and new religions. Possibly much the same? My own parents might have lost their minds had I converted to anything outside our Christian religion, come to think of it. To them, it would signal eternal damnation. I am sure the author’s family (and any other family) might also feel shamed within their communities, and within their religious congregations especially. Still, to put that much pressure upon their own son seems beyond anything I could do.

My daughter married a Taoist. I am not bothered by that. Would you be? After reading this book, and writing this insightful response to the forum question, how do you think you might react if you had a child who converted to a different religion?

It seems to me that cultural context plays a significant role in shaping our perspectives, particularly regarding religion. Coming from Europe, where religious indoctrination is less prevalent than in previous generations, I`ve been granted the freedom to choose my beliefs from an early age. As for myself, I intend to be even more open-minded with my child; I aim to offer him the same latitude of choice. Like the author of the book, we all view the world through our unique cultural lenses, just as our parents did through theirs.

I sympathize with the difficulties you've faced with your father. Sometimes, it seems parents exert control over their children out of a misguided sense of love, not realizing the full impact of their actions. As for the topic of religious conversion, I've been fortunate to have supportive parents throughout my life. While my father is quite conservative, I don't believe their reaction to any religious transition I might undertake would be as severe as what the author experienced.

In raising my own child, my highest priority is to support him in every way possible. My personal beliefs should not impede his happiness and well-being. If he feels safe, happy, fulfilled, and at peace, then I am satisfied. These ideals may seem idyllic on paper, and it's one thing to state them now, but I sincerely hope that if, in 15-20 years, my son decides to change his religion, I will stand firm in my current beliefs and support him wholeheartedly.
Is your daughter content? Is she secure and cherished? If the answer is affirmative, then you've succeeded in accepting your child's decisions and placing your trust in her.

It's fascinating to explore the cultural dynamics and varying reactions within families. The pressure and guilt trips depicted in the book seem extreme, but such reactions can indeed stem from deep cultural and religious values. Immigrants navigating new cultures and religions may face challenges in reconciling traditional beliefs with assimilation.

As for your question about having a child who converted to a different religion,it's clear that reactions can be diverse. Some individuals embrace the diversity and respect their children's choices, much like your acceptance of your daughter's choice to marry a Taoist. Others might struggle with the change, influenced by their own beliefs and societal expectations. It's a complex and personal matter, often involving a balance between individual autonomy and family expectations.

[Malleswararao Dasari]

For me, it's his conversation to Christianity because Muslims rarely explore other religions. Ali's exploration about Christianity, asking questions about religion and taking a daring a step to convert his religion surprised me the most.

[Melvis Okoye]

Ali Master's experience that surprised me is his profound transformation from adhering to his Muslim faith to discovering a new faith in Christianity. This significant spiritual change is a central theme in "Beyond the Golden Door: Seeing the American Dream Through an Immigrant's Eyes" and represents a dramatic shift in his personal beliefs and identity

[Kenechukwu Okoye]

Ali's experience that surprised me most is his transformation from Muslim Faith to Chritian Faith. It wasn't expected initially but along the line, the unpredictability of life played out

[Diana Lowery]

I was not surprised by his mother's manipulative tactics using guilt on her son. Having been exposed to this parenting technique on my students, the situation felt normal.

[Sarah Zain]

His conversion from Islam was strange to me. I cannot comprehend the idea, but no matter how much we read, there are things that we cannot explain.

[Risper Ouma Anyango]

Him almost committing suicide because of his toxic girlfriend, I understand that she was toxic and he had tried everything, but I wouldn’t think of suicide no matter what.

[Silvia Orenge]

Ali Master's experience that surprised me is his profound transformation from adhering to his Muslim faith to discovering a new faith in Christianity. This significant spiritual change is a central theme in "Beyond the Golden Door: Seeing the American Dream Through an Immigrant's Eyes" and represents a dramatic shift in his personal beliefs and identity

[Onuoha Joy]

For me, it's his conversation to Christianity because Muslims rarely explore other religions. Ali's exploration about Christianity, asking questions about religion and taking a daring a step to convert his religion surprised me the most.

[Elizabeth-Tush4Christ]

Many of the experiences in the book were predictable, given societal tendencies to react in certain ways to specific situations. However, what truly stood out to me were Ali's mother and father. Their initial reaction to the news of Ali's conversion was expected, but their subsequent behavior after confirming his new path was shocking. I didn't anticipate such deep-seated discrimination from them. Their support could have significantly impacted Ali's experience back home, making him feel safe and welcomed. This made me realize that some decisions are deeply personal, and you must bear the consequences, whether good or bad. The father's reaction was even worse than the mother's, which shook me profoundly.

[Uma gupta]

The most unexpected thing about Ali Master's experience was how much he changed—from practicing his Muslim beliefs to adopting Christianity. "Beyond the Golden Door: Seeing the American Dream Through an Immigrant's Eyes" revolves around this important spiritual transformation, which signifies a profound change in his identity and personal convictions. One potent and surprising component of his trip is his conversion, especially in light of the strong emotional and societal pressures he encountered upon returning to Karachi.