Do you think "Dumb" Orphans is an accurate depiction of the effects of HIV and AIDS in Africa?

[Melisa Jane]

This is a discussion topic for the November 2024 Book of the Month, ""Dumb" Orphans: The Bundu Bunch Trilogy" by Allan Low

Do you think "Dumb" Orphans is an accurate depiction of the effects of HIV and AIDS in Africa?

[Diana Lowery]

I don't have enough statistical information about the epidemic in Africa then or now to be able to judge the accuracy of the depiction in the book. Since this is a YA book, I think researching the validity would be an excellent classroom assignment.

[Noyamanu]

If the entire focus of the book was to shine a light on the HIV epidemic, then I don't think it was successful in that mission. Yes, the orphans' parents died due to HIV, and the CANDO center ended up helping provide a cure with wolverine oil, but those were really the only mentions. "Dumb" Orphans really felt more like a story about defeating the corrupt, what with the leader of the village whose name is slipping my mind, then Aiyasha managing to fool both the head of the school AND the head of the nation, who were both too self-absorbed to realize what was going on. It was a great story about defeating corruption and rising against the odds, but the HIV epidemic really only felt like a device to start the plot in the first place.

[Elavarasi Charles]

The book deals with indirect effects or after-effects of the pandemic disease. As HIV became widespread and took lives, the already struggling communities faced a new kind of deficiency. Where appropriate orphanages and homes are non-existent, the lives of children who lost parents and their only financial support plunged into the threat of becoming child laborers to support basic needs. Dishearteningly, to the community stained with poverty and corruption, these children were only a burden, loved and cared for by almost none in the village which had its own plate empty.

[Caroline Anne Richmond]

HiV was mentioned in the book as the reason for the children being orphans, this is how the story enables the writer to use themes such as child labour and circulation. I don't think I learned much about the HIV pandemic in south Africa, as it wasn't the main aspect of the story.

[M Grogan]

I'm a third of the way through this book, and there has been almost no mention of the HIV/AIDS crisis. I'm surprised about this because the book summary makes it seem like it will be large part of the plot. I was hoping it would be.

[Sasikala gupta]

The HIV crisis was hardly highlighted; it was just a passing statement on how the children's became orphans. I had no idea about the pandemic in South Africa and that people lost their lives due to HIV. In a way, if the target audience was children's and teens, then the author was right in not getting in depth of this situation.

[Love Ukaegbu]

No, the Hiv crisis did not stand out in this book and it doesn't really show how much it affects Africa.

[Lal Roni]

"Dumb Orphans" can be a valuable starting point for understanding the impact of HIV/AIDS in Africa. But it's essential to engage with other resources.

[Seetha E]

HIV/AIDS was only mentioned as a reason for the kids leading lives as orphans. The book does not delve into the HIV/AIDS aspect as much as the after-effects. It does get a mention again in terms of the achievements.

Having no knowledge about Africa and the impact of HIV/AIDS there, apart from another book I read, I can say that 1 common factor that stands out is that the kids are most impacted. The machinery set up to address the issues does not always seep down to the last layer.

[Natalie MT]

No, not at all. HIV/AIDS was not a focus, nor was "accurate representation" of the AIDS pandemic in Africa. They didn't super dive into the consequences of this AIDS epidemic in any substantial enough way to compare the reality. Also, this is kind of a wild question to ask a book forum full of people who may or may not have ever been to Africa/have any experience with pandemic management.

[Harshitha G B]

As I i don't know exact information about the AIDS, so i couldn't exactly know how much it matches the info.

[Ike Kass]

I wouldn’t know because I don’t know the statistical analysis of the HIV patients in Africa

[Louis Donald]

It gives a realistic view of how HIV and AIDS leave children orphaned and struggling, but it focuses more on their resilience and journey rather than the full scope of the crisis.

[Frank Edwards]

While HIV/AIDS is mentioned as the cause of the orphans’ struggles, the book focuses more on overcoming corruption than the epidemic itself. The crisis serves as a plot catalyst rather than the central theme, with the real focus on resilience and outsmarting powerful figures.