Review: Scarlet and the Keepers of Light by Brandon West

[DiDonovan]

I could have reviewed this under 'science fiction and fantasy' and I waffled a bit before deciding to post here, because the protagonist is young adult and her reactions and perceptions are very much geared to this audience - though adults won't want to miss it, either.

If your puppy suddenly grew to become twice the size of the biggest dog and began talking, wouldn't you suspect something was wrong? And if you stumbled on a prophecy that indicated that you were to play a key role in a bigger picture, what would you do?

Scarlet and the Keepers of Light presents just such a dilemma when Scarlet Hopewell discovers that her world is anything but ordinary and predictable. Her perception of reality vastly expands when the barriers between magical and non-magical worlds is breached - but that's not the end of it; it's the beginning of a very dangerous game indeed - one that's centered around Scarlet's decisions and choices.

Now, this is directed to a younger audience of pre-teen into teen readers. But the inclusion of many insights into her family and influences are what sets Scarlet and the Keepers of Light apart from your usual light fantasy read - and this is an essential ingredient: without it, Scarlet would be just another "child goes on epic quest' read. With this added flavor, it's much more.

One doesn't ordinarily anticipate the inclusion of ethical and social concerns in a quest directed at young adult and preteen audiences. One doesn't ordinarily anticipate the sweetness of world-expanding vision in a light-sounding story about falling into another reality. And one doesn't tend to believe that the first bite of cake will prove so satisfying that it should be devoured slowly, lest the pleasure end too soon.

Scarlet is an engrossing saga packed with insight and adventure but, most of all, grounded firmly in the earth of family ties and nature. And this is Scarlet and the Keepers of Light's greatest asset: one that will reach beyond its intended young audience into adult circles.

[Deee]

I loved this book. I found the protagonist Scarlet to show such strength of character not usually found in YA female leads. I wholeheartedly agree with DiDonavan that this book is packed with insight, and though it is written for a younger audience, I found myself as equally riveted and invested as I would reading my typically favored adult fantasy novels.