Review of Donny, Mary Grace and the Ugly Marbles

[Diana Lowery]

[Following is a volunteer review of "Donny, Mary Grace and the Ugly Marbles" by Catherine A. Pepe.]

---

5 out of 5 stars

---

Share This Review

---

Having read a different book in the Grandma Gang Mystery series, I was excited to read Donny, Mary Grace, and the Ugly Marbles. I like how author Catherine Anna Pepe uses her relationship with her brother, Donny, to create these fictional stories. The character of Mary Grace in Pepe's books reflects that family connection.

Mary Grace is one of the protagonists, and the reading age for this book is based on her character. Mary Grace is a mature fifth grader who demonstrates good judgment and compassion. The dialogue between Mary Grace and her brother is authentic. Because Donny has Down syndrome, his comments are often unique, but Mary Grace's responses are always thoughtful.

The setting in a facility for senior citizens allows the Grandma Gang to play a major role in solving the smuggling ring mystery. Although some of the activities might seem unrealistic, they are appropriate for a children's book. The scene where the residents sing in the hallway and block exits with their walkers and wheelchairs will appeal to eleven-year-old readers.

Several important lessons are portrayed in this third book in the series. Donny and his friend Ed are disobedient. Even though they are not punished by their families, they suffer from the consequences of their actions and learn from their mistakes. One of the characters, Mrs. Taylor, is the person responsible for causing the mystery. The lesson she learns is that if it sounds too good to be true, it probably is.

One negative I noted concerns the activities of Mrs. Taylor. Readers are never told how she became involved in the smuggling in the first place. I am sure inquisitive fifth graders would wonder the same thing. Another negative is that Donny and Ed don't seem to have any remorse for their disobedient behavior. While this may be due to the nature of their respective disabilities, I think it should have been discussed.

As with the other books in this series, this one was error-free. My rating is five out of five stars; I found no reason to deduct any points. Catherine Anna Pepe's book is entertaining and educational, a perfect addition to an elementary school library.

******
Donny, Mary Grace and the Ugly Marbles
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon