Page 1 of 20

Review of Bone Necklace

Posted: 27 Jun 2022, 04:52
by Verna Coy
[Following is an official OnlineBookClub.org review of "Bone Necklace" by Julia Sullivan.]
Book Cover
4 out of 4 stars
Share This Review


Bone Necklace by Julia Sullivan is a historical fiction novel set in the American West in 1877. After an attack by the Nez Perce Indians, Jack Peniel searches for his stepmother, Sally. Unable to find her, he joins forces with his father to deal with the Indians and possibly find peace. To make matters worse, his mule doesn't listen, and Jack is out of whiskey. Things never quite seem to come together for Jack. Will he ever be able to make his way in this war-torn frontier? To find out, you must read this book!

In just the first few chapters, I was aware of a lifetime of history belonging to Jack Peniel. It was so effortlessly woven into the storyline that it never felt like too much information. This skillful and adept writing style makes this book not only entertaining but an easy read. The flowing narrative carries a reader swiftly through from event to event seamlessly as the action mounts and the pace quickens at times.

There are welcome instances of humor in the narrative of this story that comes upon the unsuspecting reader without warning. I found myself enjoying that element on occasion. That moment of lightness would overtake the seriousness of a particular scene, such as when a hapless bugler blew his horn near the ear of Jack Penial, who was nursing a hangover.

What I liked best about this story was the excellent character development. As the reader follows Jack through one battle to another, there is a subtle transformation in how Jack views current events. The subject of right and wrong becomes a more prevalent issue, and the novel's tone changes. I feel that these aspects will resonate with readers on a deep and personal level.

As the book progresses, it is divided into four parts. Each part deals with different stages of events that affect sets of characters. This format helped break the book up and kept it from becoming tedious due to its length. The battle scenes are numerous and lengthy, and at times it felt like the story was getting lost in the long descriptions of gruesome deaths and mutilation.

I enjoyed the depth of feeling in many of the characters. The love between Running Bird and Prairie Dove was important to the novel. Their relationship echoed the strength and bond of people throughout generations who have lived through times of war. Readers will enjoy how vivid and intense the character's personalities are in this story.

I found nothing too negative to mention about this book. It is exceptionally well edited and without error. It employs fictional characters that are supported by the foundation of true history. This tactic has given the book depth of feeling along with historical accuracy. I especially enjoyed how it included photos of historical characters. For these reasons, it has achieved a rating of 4 out of 4 stars.

I recommend this book to readers who enjoy a novel that takes them back in time and delivers a close account of what it was like during the Indian wars. It will appeal most to students of history who love a good story. This book has frequent severe profanity scattered throughout. The grotesque injuries, gruesome scenes, massacres, and violence that one would expect when reading about Indian wars are present in this novel. Therefore it is best suited to a mature audience. Fans of historical novels set in the American West will enjoy this book.

******
Bone Necklace
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon

Re: Review of Bone Necklace

Posted: 14 Jul 2022, 10:47
by Fearnia Laurel
This seems to be a well-written historical fiction; accurately depicted story based on true history, good character development, skillful narrative. Thank you for the review.

Re: Review of Bone Necklace

Posted: 26 Dec 2022, 08:43
by Jorge Leon Salazar
This historical fiction novel is set in the American West during the Indian Wars. It seems to have several attractive aspects such as the excellent development of the characters, touches of humor, and depth of feelings in many of the characters. However, the severe profanities and violence make it suitable only for a mature audience.

Re: Review of Bone Necklace

Posted: 26 Dec 2022, 08:51
by Sou Hi
Congrats on BOTD. Those who are interested in the Nez Perce tribe and their battle against the U.S. Army will enjoy this historical novel.

Re: Review of Bone Necklace

Posted: 26 Dec 2022, 08:58
by NetMassimo
Historical fiction is not my thing but this novel offers insights into a tragic part of US history I know very little about. It uses fiction to tell some ugly truths about an ugly American war. Thank you for your great review!

Re: Review of Bone Necklace

Posted: 26 Dec 2022, 09:02
by tarafarah7
Today's BOTD is an historical fiction novel set in the American West in 1877. Readers will enjoy the action-packed, high suspense scenes, as well as the distinct personalities of each character. Those who enjoy stories of war, especially ones about individuals whose lives were transformed as a result, will be fully engaged from start to finish. Thank you for the helpful review! :-)

Re: Review of Bone Necklace

Posted: 26 Dec 2022, 09:13
by Margi zuu202
Book 📖📖of the day BOTD is historical fiction dating back in the 18th century a tale of surviving in which Nez Perce over come staggering odd but also win the grudging respect of war weary nation while deeply rooted in American history the story continue to resonate illuminating modern debete around institutional racism, journalistic bias and the call for courage in time's of moral crisis.. the story was well written I picture the events in this book reading it and it was also given a nice review making it easier to understand I will recommend it 💯✅ 📖

Re: Review of Bone Necklace

Posted: 26 Dec 2022, 09:21
by María Andrea Fernández Sepúlveda
There are welcome instances of humor in the narrative of this story that comes upon the unsuspecting reader without warning. I found myself enjoying that element on occasion. That moment of lightness would overtake the seriousness of a particular scene, such as when a hapless bugler blew his horn near the ear of Jack Penial, who was nursing a hangover.
That's funny :D And I always cherish that authors take the time, even in serious books, for a bit of humor.
What I liked best about this story was the excellent character development. As the reader follows Jack through one battle to another, there is a subtle transformation in how Jack views current events. The subject of right and wrong becomes a more prevalent issue, and the novel's tone changes. I feel that these aspects will resonate with readers on a deep and personal level.
I love it when we can see characters grow along the plot. Stagnant characters just don't feel realistic, and I never get as involved.

Good review!

Re: Review of Bone Necklace

Posted: 26 Dec 2022, 09:31
by Abimbola Oladokun
Although historical fiction is one of my favorite genres, the concept of the American war is not something I'm interested in reading. All the same, congratulations on being the BOTD.

Re: Review of Bone Necklace

Posted: 26 Dec 2022, 09:43
by Grace Elkana
Even for historical fiction books, humor is a welcome addition. I believe this book will be interesting.

Re: Review of Bone Necklace

Posted: 26 Dec 2022, 09:49
by Ekuma Blessing
Historical fiction is not my kind but the transformation was sparking, the love between running bird and prairie does get me inspired. Excellent review! Congratulations on the BOTD.

Re: Review of Bone Necklace

Posted: 26 Dec 2022, 09:56
by Amy Luman
Im glad to hear of Jack's change in attitude.

Re: Review of Bone Necklace

Posted: 26 Dec 2022, 10:05
by Brenda Creech
I love historical novels; however, I don't care for strong profanity and violent and lengthy war scenes! I also enjoy historical novels with a romance in the mix, so I hate missing that part, but I just don't feel like reading a lot of violent content at this time! Thanks for the excellent review!

Re: Review of Bone Necklace

Posted: 26 Dec 2022, 10:11
by Bertha Jackson
I have only come across a few books about the Indian wars. I am glad this book includes humor about these devastating times in our history. Thank you for your review.

Re: Review of Bone Necklace

Posted: 26 Dec 2022, 10:53
by Edward Tuya
Today's BOTD is an action-packed, entertaining historical fiction set in the American West in the late 19th century. It's about a fight for survival between the native Indian tribe of Nez Perce and the new arrivals, the Americans. Great book for fans of history and action! Thanks for your review and congratulations on BOTD.