Review of Daughters of green mountain gap

[Okoth Onyango Victor]

[Following is an official OnlineBookClub.org review of "Daughters of green mountain gap" by Teri m brown.]

---

4 out of 5 stars

---

Share This Review

---

Daughters of Green Mountain Gap by Teri M. Brown unfolds the captivating tale of Josie Mae, a young girl navigating life in the late 19th-century Appalachian mountains. Her journey is intricately woven with themes of herbal healing, familial expectations, and the clash between traditional and modern medicine. Josie Mae's character evolves through her interactions with her grandmother, Maggie, who imparts knowledge of herbs and healing. Collaborating with Dr. McKeithen at his clinic, Josie Mae aspires to deepen her medical expertise. However, her mother, Carrie Ann, rigidly insists on prioritizing domestic duties over her pursuit of medicine. This conflict sets the stage for a narrative that becomes both poignant and gripping.

The narrative skillfully explores the strong bonds connecting generations of women. Maggie, Josie Mae, and Carrie Ann are intricately linked through their shared dedication to medicine and healing. The story becomes a tribute to the traditional herbal practices and healing wisdom passed down through generations of "granny women." It gracefully underscores the importance of preserving these traditions, portraying them with respect and reverence. The vivid portrayal of the challenges faced by women in rural Appalachia during the late 19th century forms a compelling backdrop. The narrative brings forth their resilience and mutual support, painting a picture of complex family dynamics. The relationships among the main characters are rendered with depth and nuance, capturing the intricacies of familial bonds in the face of adversity.

However, amidst its strengths, the novel grapples with some shortcomings. The depiction of medical practices from the late 19th century may be viewed as outdated or potentially harmful by modern standards. Herbal remedies and folk healing methods, while integral to the story, may not align with contemporary scientific and medical standards, potentially overshadowing the importance of evidence-based medicine. Moreover, the tension portrayed between traditional and modern medicine introduces a nuanced conflict, with some characters resisting or distrusting newer medical approaches, which could perpetuate misunderstandings. In conclusion, Daughters of Green Mountain Gap earns a commendable 4 out of 5 stars rating. The book is impeccably edited, devoid of errors, and is recommended for readers intrigued by narratives that delve into the world of herbal medicines and the intricate dynamics of family and healing in historical Appalachia.

******
Daughters of green mountain gap
View: on Bookshelves

[Harriet Kajuju]

A poignant exploration of tradition versus innovation, heritage versus progress, and the human struggle to reconcile the wisdom of the past with the advancements of the present. What a beautiful story is painted in this review.

[Kanchan Bhil]

Reading your review makes me wonder if Josie Mae managed to balance her domestic duties and her passion. Even though in the 19th century, it would have been difficult to follow one's passion, I hope she got what she wanted! You have put forth great points about herbal medicine of the 19th century and modern medicine. It was a delight to read your review.

[Nwansimdi Mercy Someze]

The clash between her ambitions and her mother's traditional views creates a poignant and gripping dynamic, promising a captivating exploration of themes in this historical tale.

[Shinshinshin]

The review for "Daughters of Green Mountain Gap" by Teri M. Brown presents a captivating story set in 19th-century Appalachia, highlighting the importance of herbal healing and intergenerational connections. However, the portrayal of outdated medical practices and potential misunderstandings regarding evidence-based medicine may be seen as drawbacks. Overall, the book seems to be a good read for those interested in historical Appalachia and herbal medicine, earning a commendable 4 out of 5 stars rating.