Page 1 of 1

Typo or Spelling Error or Incorrect word usage - A second opinion would be appreciated.

Posted: 09 Mar 2023, 13:25
by Jess Pumkin
Hi there

Please can I get a second opinion on the error in the following sentence:"She didn’t remember, but she probably had a strong fear of living in some sort of orphanage with a bunch of ragged, retched things."

Herewith is how I've considered the error. Any guidance would be appreciated.

Thanks
J
___________________________


Error 1: Uncounted: Typo (missing letter) or incorrect word usage:
Retched - wretched : She didn’t remember, but she probably had a strong fear of living in some sort of orphanage with a bunch of ragged, retched things.

Explanation:
The word being used is "retched", and this I am sure means "vomit" in both American and UK English. Perhaps the writer means the orphans are ragged, vomited out beings, in which case this is not an error. I would think though, in the way the sentence is flowing, that the character is expressing that orphans are ragged, wretched beings; "wretched" meaning, unhappy miserable and unfortunate creatures - which works well when describing orphans.

Re: Typo or Spelling Error or Incorrect word usage - A second opinion would be appreciated.

Posted: 09 Mar 2023, 16:04
by MsH2k
Jess Pumkin wrote: 09 Mar 2023, 13:25 Hi there

Please can I get a second opinion on the error in the following sentence:"She didn’t remember, but she probably had a strong fear of living in some sort of orphanage with a bunch of ragged, retched things."

Herewith is how I've considered the error. Any guidance would be appreciated.

Thanks
J
___________________________


Error 1: Uncounted: Typo (missing letter) or incorrect word usage:
Retched - wretched : She didn’t remember, but she probably had a strong fear of living in some sort of orphanage with a bunch of ragged, retched things.

Explanation:
The word being used is "retched", and this I am sure means "vomit" in both American and UK English. Perhaps the writer means the orphans are ragged, vomited out beings, in which case this is not an error. I would think though, in the way the sentence is flowing, that the character is expressing that orphans are ragged, wretched beings; "wretched" meaning, unhappy miserable and unfortunate creatures - which works well when describing orphans.
I would agree that this is an uncounted error, and your explanation is spot on. :handgestures-thumbupright:

Re: Typo or Spelling Error or Incorrect word usage - A second opinion would be appreciated.

Posted: 09 Mar 2023, 22:29
by Jess Pumkin
:tiphat: Thank you.