Sherlock or Poirot?
Authors and publishers are not able to post replies in the review topics.
-
- Posts: 38
- Joined: 06 Jul 2023, 11:07
- Currently Reading: Waterworks
- Bookshelf Size: 23
Re: Sherlock or Poirot?
It's quite clear, even without too much research that one of Agatha Christie's most significant influence in creating the figure of Poirot was the well-known Sherlock Holmes, and she also admitted it herself. So, Holmes has the advantage of being there first.
The two figures have some similarities, mostly their being bachelors, their exceptional abilities, their crew, etc. They also have dissimilarities – the most obvious is Poirot being a foreigner, a complete stranger to the British culture he lives in. However, these are mostly circumstantial. When I observe the personality of the two detectives, as most eccentric as both detectives are, I find the figure of Holmes much more human. Here's why:
- Holmes is less arrogant than Poirot. He sometimes boasts about his abilities and "the science of deduction", but this is mostly in the face of Dr Watson, and not in the presence of other people, while Poirot keeps boasting about his "little gray cells" in front of almost anyone who listens to him, and always regards himself as the most important person around. Christie herself couldn't bear his character (Wikipedia - By 1930, Agatha Christie found Poirot "insufferable", and by 1960 she felt that he was a "detestable, bombastic, tiresome, ego-centric little creep").
- Holmes is very successful, but sometimes makes mistakes. He sometimes fails. He has some equal rivals that beat him in a few occasions. I refer to Irene Adler in "A Scandal in Bohemia", Professor Moriarty, which finds him and kills him, in a fight in which they both lose their lives in "The Last Problem" (Well, we know that, later, Holmes is brought back to life). Holmes even believes, for a moment that he failed to guard Sir Henry Baskerville, until, luckily, it turns out that the victim is the criminal Selden, and not Baskerville. Maybe there are some more examples that I don't remember.
- Holmes has weaknesses – he is sometimes under depression, he uses drugs. In comparison, Poirot hardly has flaws.
- Holmes is a man of wide horizons – he plays the violin, he writes scientific monographs, and he even writes some of the stories – for example, "The Lion's Mane". I don't recall any similar feature in Poirot.
These facts are some of the reasons why I like Holmes much more than Poirot. I stress, again, that I related here only to the personalities, and not to the literary qualities of the stories and novels themselves.
- Kebun Bunga
- Book of the Month Participant
- Posts: 351
- Joined: 22 May 2023, 01:26
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 113
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-kebun-bunga.html
- Latest Review: Telling Your Story, Developing Your Brand by Henry Wong
Sondang
- Onyinyechi Obi
- In It Together VIP
- Posts: 186
- Joined: 02 Dec 2023, 09:29
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 46
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-onyinyechi-obi.html
- Latest Review: The Assignment by Shayla C. Freeman
-
- Book of the Month Participant
- Posts: 288
- Joined: 15 Jul 2023, 09:22
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 37
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-andrew-darlington.html
- Latest Review: Alpha Buddies Land by Donna Marie Rink
- Onyinyechi Obi
- In It Together VIP
- Posts: 186
- Joined: 02 Dec 2023, 09:29
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 46
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-onyinyechi-obi.html
- Latest Review: The Assignment by Shayla C. Freeman
- Priya Murugesan
- Posts: 520
- Joined: 27 Jan 2020, 01:51
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 48
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-priya-murugesan.html
- Latest Review: Homecoming Heist by Tyson Collin
-
- Book of the Month Participant
- Posts: 109
- Joined: 17 Nov 2023, 13:47
- Currently Reading: The Rock at the Bottom
- Bookshelf Size: 29
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-loretta-morris-1.html
- Latest Review: Enlightenment for the Things that Really Matter by Mark Gumbrell
- Reading Device: B00I15SB16
- 2024 Reading Goal: 75
- 2024 Goal Completion: 52%
Yes Sherlock Holmes, is known for his proficiency with observation, deduction, forensic science and logical reasoning that borders on the fantastic, which he employs when investigating cases for a wide variety of clients, including Scotland Yard. He is one of America's favorite!
-
- Posts: 38
- Joined: 06 Jul 2023, 11:07
- Currently Reading: Waterworks
- Bookshelf Size: 23
"one of America's favorite" ?Loretta Morris 1 wrote: ↑27 Feb 2024, 20:24 Hi!
Yes Sherlock Holmes, is known for his proficiency with observation, deduction, forensic science and logical reasoning that borders on the fantastic, which he employs when investigating cases for a wide variety of clients, including Scotland Yard. He is one of America's favorite!
Well, I don't know what you meant by that, since Sherlock Holmes is a complete Englishman (although a bit eccentric).
However, this is an oportunity to recall what I would call Sherlock Holmes' half American novels - the novels (which I highly recommend) in which half the plot happens in America - "A study in Scarlet" and "The Valey of Fear". The american parts of these novels seem like westerners to me.
In addition, I can recall at least 1 story that has an american background - "The Five Orange Pips", which deals with the KKK.
- Julie Basil
- Book of the Month Participant
- Posts: 227
- Joined: 15 Jun 2023, 18:36
- Favorite Book: The Little Prince
- Currently Reading: Circe
- Bookshelf Size: 204
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-julie-basil.html
- Latest Review: Launchpad Republic by Howard Wolk and John Landry
- Reading Device: B00JG8GOWU
- Princewill Uchenna
- Book of the Month Participant
- Posts: 190
- Joined: 29 Oct 2023, 12:32
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 39
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-princewill-uchenna.html
- Latest Review: Tyrants, Tormentors and the Tiara by James J Meadows III
- Badger Martin
- In It Together VIP
- Posts: 258
- Joined: 02 May 2024, 10:42
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 22
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-badger-martin.html
- Latest Review: Alpha Buddies Land by Donna Marie Rink
-
- Book of the Month Participant
- Posts: 186
- Joined: 29 Aug 2023, 20:53
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 15