Review of An Island Long Ago
-
Viviana Libreros
- Posts: 12
- Joined: 13 Dec 2022, 15:32
- Currently Reading: The Sleepeasy Solution
- Bookshelf Size: 337
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-viviana-libreros.html
- Latest Review: An Island Long Ago by Julie Burnette
Review of An Island Long Ago
[Following is an official OnlineBookClub.org review of "An Island Long Ago" by Julie Burnette.]
"An Island Long Ago" by Julie Burnette presents an intriguing tapestry of historical romance set against the vivid backdrop of the Philippines, spanning generations. While the novel is well written, unfolding a multi-layered story of love, betrayal, and cultural shifts, my experience with grants it 3 out of 5 stars.
The book's strengths are numerous, offering a richly detailed narrative that transports readers through time, providing a deep dive into the complexities of family sagas and the inevitable intertwining of personal and historical upheavals. Burnette's craftsmanship in character development and setting description is notable, creating a world that feels both expansive and intimate. The portrayal of the Philippines, from its lush landscapes to the nuanced depiction of its historical context, is particularly compelling, adding a robust layer of authenticity to the tale.
However, despite these good aspects, the novel's pacing proves to be its Achilles' heel. The story's flow, while intricate, often feels unnecessarily slow, with certain sections dragging on without advancing the plot or enriching the characters in meaningful ways. This sluggish pace, combined with a tendency towards superfluous action, detracts from the narrative's overall impact, leaving a sense of unfulfilled potential in its wake.
Furthermore, while the historical setting is one of the book's highlights, it occasionally overshadows the personal dramas unfolding within. The balance between the grand sweep of history and the intimate moments of character interaction sometimes tips too far in favor of the former, making the latter seem less compelling than they might otherwise have been.
In terms of presentation, the book demonstrates a commendable level of editing, with few typographical or grammatical errors to note. This attention to detail in the editing process is noteworthy, as it is indeed rare for a book to exhibit such polish.
In conclusion, "An Island Long Ago" is a novel with much to admire, from its ambitious scope to its detailed setting and complex characters. However, its pacing issues and occasional focus on less engaging aspects slightly mar the reading experience. I recommend it to fans of historical romance, particularly those with an interest in the rich cultural and historical tapestry of the Philippines. It stands as a testament to Julie Burnette's ability to weave a complex narrative, even if it doesn't quite achieve the heights it could have.
******
An Island Long Ago
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon
"An Island Long Ago" by Julie Burnette presents an intriguing tapestry of historical romance set against the vivid backdrop of the Philippines, spanning generations. While the novel is well written, unfolding a multi-layered story of love, betrayal, and cultural shifts, my experience with grants it 3 out of 5 stars.
The book's strengths are numerous, offering a richly detailed narrative that transports readers through time, providing a deep dive into the complexities of family sagas and the inevitable intertwining of personal and historical upheavals. Burnette's craftsmanship in character development and setting description is notable, creating a world that feels both expansive and intimate. The portrayal of the Philippines, from its lush landscapes to the nuanced depiction of its historical context, is particularly compelling, adding a robust layer of authenticity to the tale.
However, despite these good aspects, the novel's pacing proves to be its Achilles' heel. The story's flow, while intricate, often feels unnecessarily slow, with certain sections dragging on without advancing the plot or enriching the characters in meaningful ways. This sluggish pace, combined with a tendency towards superfluous action, detracts from the narrative's overall impact, leaving a sense of unfulfilled potential in its wake.
Furthermore, while the historical setting is one of the book's highlights, it occasionally overshadows the personal dramas unfolding within. The balance between the grand sweep of history and the intimate moments of character interaction sometimes tips too far in favor of the former, making the latter seem less compelling than they might otherwise have been.
In terms of presentation, the book demonstrates a commendable level of editing, with few typographical or grammatical errors to note. This attention to detail in the editing process is noteworthy, as it is indeed rare for a book to exhibit such polish.
In conclusion, "An Island Long Ago" is a novel with much to admire, from its ambitious scope to its detailed setting and complex characters. However, its pacing issues and occasional focus on less engaging aspects slightly mar the reading experience. I recommend it to fans of historical romance, particularly those with an interest in the rich cultural and historical tapestry of the Philippines. It stands as a testament to Julie Burnette's ability to weave a complex narrative, even if it doesn't quite achieve the heights it could have.
******
An Island Long Ago
View: on Bookshelves | on Amazon
Latest Review: An Island Long Ago by Julie Burnette
