Review of On the Stoop
-
christopher_robin
- Posts: 31
- Joined: 19 Oct 2024, 16:05
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 6
- Reviewer Page: onlinebookclub.org/reviews/by-christopher-robin.html
- Latest Review: At Vitoria by Marcia Riman Selz
Review of On the Stoop
[Following is an official OnlineBookClub.org review of "On the Stoop" by Ron Semple.]
On the Stoop is a nostalgic and vivid memoir by Ron Semple, offering a personal journey through the mid-20th century in Jersey City and its surrounding areas. Through Semple’s storytelling, we glimpse a world that no longer exists—a tough, gritty, yet vibrant working-class environment filled with ethnic diversity, strong family ties, and a deep sense of community.
The strength of this book is in the vivid description of a "vanished world." The minute details from Semple breathe life into the far-fetched neighborhoods, traditions, and personalities that define Jersey City. The historical context is rich in this narration, going from the after-effects of World War II to the Great Depression and even into the post-war boom. These historical events frame the book as much as a social history as they do a personal memoir through the prism of daily life.
Semple's voice rings out with authenticity: humorous, affectionate, often irreverent. The stories of family life, neighborhood interactions, and childhood adventures are highly personal and universal. There's a great sense of belonging, and in his character sketches of the tough-yet-loving grandmother or hardworking grandfather, emotional depth is brought into the memoir.
However, this is not a perfect book in every respect. I mean, sometimes the story goes on with drag; likewise, the nostalgia is equally tantalizing. Some parts are too wordy, which is when the tempo drags; this may remove a reader from the reading experience. This especially applies to readers for whom the era or place in question does not resonate at all. Additionally, entertaining as they are, the personal stories at times seem a bit fragmented, as if Semple were to put almost every recollection into the book without considering its entire structure.
The editing in the book is good: there are only a few minor typos throughout, and so they did not detract too much from the readability. A more rigorous edit may also have tidied up some of the slower sections and made the transition between different anecdotes easier.
As far as improvements go, the memoir could have had a more defined narrative arc. There are instances where the book reads like a series of related vignettes but not exactly tied together. Perhaps digging deeper into thematic elements or being even more chronological in the approach would make this an even more engaging read. All in all, On the Stoop is a charming and heartfelt memoir that personalizes experiences for people either with a personal affection for Jersey City or those who simply love mid-century American life stories. I would award this book a 4 out of 5 stars. Though not perfect in its presentation, its charm and authenticity make it overpoweringly worth reading for those interested in history, nostalgia, and family life foibles in a world going through rapid changes.
******
On the Stoop
View: on Bookshelves
On the Stoop is a nostalgic and vivid memoir by Ron Semple, offering a personal journey through the mid-20th century in Jersey City and its surrounding areas. Through Semple’s storytelling, we glimpse a world that no longer exists—a tough, gritty, yet vibrant working-class environment filled with ethnic diversity, strong family ties, and a deep sense of community.
The strength of this book is in the vivid description of a "vanished world." The minute details from Semple breathe life into the far-fetched neighborhoods, traditions, and personalities that define Jersey City. The historical context is rich in this narration, going from the after-effects of World War II to the Great Depression and even into the post-war boom. These historical events frame the book as much as a social history as they do a personal memoir through the prism of daily life.
Semple's voice rings out with authenticity: humorous, affectionate, often irreverent. The stories of family life, neighborhood interactions, and childhood adventures are highly personal and universal. There's a great sense of belonging, and in his character sketches of the tough-yet-loving grandmother or hardworking grandfather, emotional depth is brought into the memoir.
However, this is not a perfect book in every respect. I mean, sometimes the story goes on with drag; likewise, the nostalgia is equally tantalizing. Some parts are too wordy, which is when the tempo drags; this may remove a reader from the reading experience. This especially applies to readers for whom the era or place in question does not resonate at all. Additionally, entertaining as they are, the personal stories at times seem a bit fragmented, as if Semple were to put almost every recollection into the book without considering its entire structure.
The editing in the book is good: there are only a few minor typos throughout, and so they did not detract too much from the readability. A more rigorous edit may also have tidied up some of the slower sections and made the transition between different anecdotes easier.
As far as improvements go, the memoir could have had a more defined narrative arc. There are instances where the book reads like a series of related vignettes but not exactly tied together. Perhaps digging deeper into thematic elements or being even more chronological in the approach would make this an even more engaging read. All in all, On the Stoop is a charming and heartfelt memoir that personalizes experiences for people either with a personal affection for Jersey City or those who simply love mid-century American life stories. I would award this book a 4 out of 5 stars. Though not perfect in its presentation, its charm and authenticity make it overpoweringly worth reading for those interested in history, nostalgia, and family life foibles in a world going through rapid changes.
******
On the Stoop
View: on Bookshelves
Latest Review: At Vitoria by Marcia Riman Selz
-
Maureen Mire
- Posts: 13
- Joined: 14 Sep 2024, 00:34
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 3
- Reading Device: B00JG8GOWU
- 2025 Reading Goal: 1000
- 2025 Goal Completion: 0%
This is such a thorough review,one of my best. I would love to adopt your style of review.
-
Nneka Bridget
- Book of the Month Participant
- Posts: 212
- Joined: 09 Oct 2024, 08:27
- Currently Reading:
- Bookshelf Size: 15
"On the Stoop" by Ron Semple offers a heartfelt glimpse into mid-20th century Jersey City, blending personal anecdotes with rich historical context. Semple’s authentic voice brings to life the vibrant community and familial bonds that defined his upbringing.
