Did you agree with everything in this book?

Post by **Melisa Jane** » 10 Feb 2024, 03:05

This is a discussion topic for the February 2024 Book of the Month, "Beyond the Golden Door: Seeing the American Dream Through an Immigrant's Eyes" by Ali Master.

Did you agree with everything in this book?

Cristina-Ioana Toader · Post by **Cristina-Ioana Toader** » 11 Feb 2024, 10:05

A particular statement towards the book's end intrigued me: "People in many parts of the world claim to live in a free society. But do they really?" This prompted the author to compare the freedoms experienced in Pakistan with those in America, presenting a binary view that might narrow our understanding of freedom.
It's crucial to acknowledge that no society embodies perfect freedom. Evaluating a country's freedom level requires a comprehensive analysis of political rights, civil liberties, economic freedom, the rule of law, and respect for fundamental human rights. I wish to tread carefully here, aiming not to offend but to broaden the discussion by highlighting that countries like the Nordic nations (Finland, Sweden, Norway, and Denmark), Japan, Australia, New Zealand, and Ireland are often celebrated for their democratic governance, press freedom, and social equality. These examples illustrate that while many countries strive for freedom, each faces unique challenges and areas for improvement.
My intention is to emphasize the diversity and complexity of freedom across the globe. This reflection on the author's comparison invites us to consider a wider array of experiences and governance models, reminding us of the varied landscapes of liberty we navigate and the continuous efforts required to uphold and enhance freedoms in our societies.

Post by **Nenye Lauraa** » 13 Feb 2024, 06:52

Cristina-Ioana Toader wrote: ↑11 Feb 2024, 10:05 A particular statement towards the book's end intrigued me: "People in many parts of the world claim to live in a free society. But do they really?" This prompted the author to compare the freedoms experienced in Pakistan with those in America, presenting a binary view that might narrow our understanding of freedom.
It's crucial to acknowledge that no society embodies perfect freedom. Evaluating a country's freedom level requires a comprehensive analysis of political rights, civil liberties, economic freedom, the rule of law, and respect for fundamental human rights. I wish to tread carefully here, aiming not to offend but to broaden the discussion by highlighting that countries like the Nordic nations (Finland, Sweden, Norway, and Denmark), Japan, Australia, New Zealand, and Ireland are often celebrated for their democratic governance, press freedom, and social equality. These examples illustrate that while many countries strive for freedom, each faces unique challenges and areas for improvement.
My intention is to emphasize the diversity and complexity of freedom across the globe. This reflection on the author's comparison invites us to consider a wider array of experiences and governance models, reminding us of the varied landscapes of liberty we navigate and the continuous efforts required to uphold and enhance freedoms in our societies.

Wow! I never really thought or analyzed the statement like that, but this is insightful. Thanks for your take on the subject.

Post by **Christabel nmeso** » 25 Feb 2024, 11:59

I found myself in a place of understanding with this book, so no, there wasn't anything I found disagreeable. The perspectives offered were insightful and resonated with me.

Post by **Diana Lowery** » 15 Mar 2024, 06:56

The use of the absolute word "everything" requires me to answer no to this question. I do agree with most things in the book, however.

Amy Luman · Post by **Amy Luman** » 25 Mar 2024, 10:59

Of course not. Agreeing with everything would make it seem like Masters and I are the very same person. Having said that, I am compelled to say that we have very similar perceptions.

Post by **Chikamnele Favour** » 29 Apr 2024, 04:22

I won't say I agree with everything in the book but I agree with 70% of the content in this book.

Ashley Hodgins · Post by **Ashley Hodgins** » 18 May 2024, 08:30

I didn't read this book to agree or disagree with the author, it's his story and not my place to tell him he is right or wrong or that I agree or disagree with what he wrote. It was his journey and his perception of his experiences.

Jenna Padayachee · Post by **Jenna Padayachee** » 23 May 2024, 14:30

I enjoyed Ali's story. I appreciate that he was able to find liberation and success in America.
I don't agree with some of the choices he made in terms of his religious experiences ( these choices were obviously suited for his own liberation), but I do respect that these are the choices that make sense to him. I am born Christian and have opted for a non-religious approach for my own life. However, I have found Ali's overall sense, spirit, and optimism encouraging.

Kevin Kipngeno · Post by **Kevin Kipngeno** » 29 May 2024, 06:03

Well, I have never been to the United States to claim that everything the author gave was right. I can, therefore, not say that I agree with everything but I would rather say that I will wait to prove all the details if one day I will be there. America, as explained by the author, seems to be the land to be admired by everyone, and I would like to confirm this.

Uma gupta · Post by **Uma gupta** » 14 Jun 2024, 02:51

The author compares freedoms in Pakistan and America, highlighting the binary view of freedom. However, evaluating a country's freedom requires a comprehensive analysis of political, civil, economic, rule of law, and human rights. So I did not accept everything in this book..